quote:
Often, they lack one of the 5 tools -- such as a poor 60 -- but the are very good players and may have superior skills in areas not tested in typical showcase.
Birdman,
I think I know what you mean, but just about every player that ever lived is lacking at least one of the 5 tools. Most anyone who would have a high grade in at least 3 tools, sometimes just two tools, would be a Pro prospect.
Typical showcase, at least a good one, would show running ability (not just 60 time), Fielding ability, throwing abilty, hitting ability and power (the 5 tools). Then they will also play in at least a couple games. Those would be the areas "tested" at a "good" typical showcase. I'm all for college camps, but what do they test for there, regarding ability, that would be any different?
We prefer seeing a player at a showcase event and also seeing him compete in games that are meaningful against high level talent. Fortunately, we have that opportunity more often than not. The two together (Showcase and Meaningful Games) can show some things that either one by itself might miss.
However, I can only think of one reason why a college coach would say, if you do not have a skill, you would be better off spending your money attending a college camp.
I would have to agree with others who say, if you do not have a skill, why spend money trying to impress people who are looking for skills?