Skip to main content

One of the players I follow on milb.com has been told to report to the Arizona Fall League. My understanding is the AFL is for prospects projected to ultimately make the MLB roster. 

 

The player in mind signed for significant money. But he was passed at his position by a younger prospect who has had his position changed after moving up past him. The reason is there's no way in hell anyone is going to play their specific position on the MLB team (stuck behind an all star). 

 

It would make sense to change this player's position to the one possible place he could eventually compete for a major league roster spot. But even then he would be stuck behind two or three more highly regarded players. The one position is the only conceivable position opening in the next two years he could win at the MLB level.

 

The MLB organization could lose this player in the Rule 5 draft in two years. While he has potential his organization is loaded with prospects making it difficult to be placed on the forty man roster.

 

Would a prospect be sent to fall instructional for showcasing for a possible trade? His stock is at it's highest point based on this season. The reason I ask is any organization loaded with prospects is prime for trading a package of them for an established player.

 

If my explanation seems a little vague I'm trying not to identify the player. 

 

 

** The dream is free. Work ethic sold separately. **

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by fanofgame:

The scenario you describe happens to players on every milb team that exists.

Hah, exactly.

 

RJM, you may think the most important variable in pro ball is performance. That's not quite it. You touched one of of the more important variables - signing bonus. That is true, but not the biggest factor.

 

THE biggest factor is age-adjusted performance - as you also touched on. Youth trumps all. Such is life, my friend.

Originally Posted by Kyle Boddy:
Originally Posted by fanofgame:

The scenario you describe happens to players on every milb team that exists.

Hah, exactly.

 

RJM, you may think the most important variable in pro ball is performance. That's not quite it. You touched one of of the more important variables - signing bonus. That is true, but not the biggest factor.

 

THE biggest factor is age-adjusted performance - as you also touched on. Youth trumps all. Such is life, my friend.

I'm very aware performance isn't the end all in the minors. A kid may be told to learn to throw or hit a certain way regardless of end result. It's why even with the kids I follow on Milb it's hard to really know how they're doing unless their results (stats) are at one extreme or the other. 

 

I've always seen the fall leagues as instructional for adjustments or learning a new position. Sometimes it's for late draft signees (more so when the deadline was 8/15) to get in some playing time for the season to be evaluated against pros.

 

It makes sense to me the team holding this players contract would showcase him to be packaged in a trade before losing him in the Rule 5 draft because their organization is loaded with prospects.

 

I was wondering if player are sent to the fall instructional league for showcasing. Come to think of it, there may be a potential trade in the works where another team said they want to see him play x position. I just never saw fall instructional as an avenue to showcase. I thought it was for prospects a team wants to improve.

The Arizona fall league is seperate from instructional leagues teams have in the fall.  Not that you dont have an opportunity to get better but its purpose is a showcase league for reasons stated.
BTW that league was where Justbaseball's son was seen by the Nationals GM when he was in the Padres system.

Add Reply

Post
.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×