Just thought I would update this since we visited Flagler a couple of weeks ago. Last year was their first as D2 and they did OK - had a winning season and made it to their conference tournament. They are the only Florida team in the Peach Belt conference, traveling mostly to southern Georgia, South Carolina, and Alabama, and also play the Florida D2s. They are expensive compared to a public school, but not compared to the other D2s in Florida.
Head Coach Barnett has been there 22 or so years. He was very approachable and answered all of our questions. Two new assistant coaches have been hired - both just out of college/pro ball. Jonathan Holt is the recruiting coordinator/pitching coach. We didn't meet the other guy. Coach Holt was on the U. Tampa D2 national championship team a few years ago and then spent 2-3 years in the Indians organization (I think). Very personable and enthusiastic. Both he and Coach Barnett were right up front about the depth chart - we didn't have to ask. They had it posted right on the wall and went over it in detail.
Facilities are not spectacular, but they're serviceable. They are doing about $1.2 million in improvements over the off-season.
The school itself is a small liberal arts college, middle of the road academically but Coach Barnett does very much appreciate good grades. They only accept 25% of applicants, but part of that is that they just get so many - who doesn't want to go to school on the beach? No science or math majors, which might be a sticking point for us, but that's still under consideration. Good school if you want to be a teacher. They have pre-law and sports management. Beautiful campus. Someone told me that it wasn't air conditioned, but don't worry - it is!
I did in fact check studentsreview.com. It seems that if you want to go to a party school, this isn't it.