"Back in the day":
As much as I still worship the greatest ballplayer ever, Willie Mays, Yaz gets my vote for the best clutch guy I've seen in my lifetime.(1954 to present and counting)
Modern day:
Here's an unexpected one: Craig Counsel. I just like this guy. He's too small, too slow, and too a lot of things, but he seems to always get the job done.
Original Post