Skip to main content

This was in our paper today.

Little League - Umpire bans Spanish on field

An umpire ordered players on a local Little League team to stop speaking Spanish during a (Mass.) state tournament game this week, a decision the coach said demoralized the team and cost it the game.
“This never should have happened,” coach Chris Mosher told the Eagle-Tribune newspaper. “These are 14-year-old kids who should not have to deal with any of this, especially in Little League baseball.”

National Little League spokesman Lance Van Auken said there’s no rule against players speaking Spanish or any other language on the field. But he said it’s too late to reverse the decision or the outcome of the game.

Mosher said he tried to file a protest after the game, but under league rules, protests must be filed before the game ends.

“It appears the umpire was concerned that the coach or manager may have been using a language other than English ... to communicate potentially ’illegal’ instructions to his players,” Van Auken said in an e-mail to The Associated Press Friday. “The umpire simply overstepped his authority, and there was no malicious intent.”

Mosher said the incident happened Tuesday night during a Junior Little League game against Seekonk in Lakeville.

Methuen was winning 3-1 when assistant coach Domingo Infante instructed the pitcher in Spanish to try to pick off a runner at second base. After the unsuccessful attempt, the umpire called time-out and spoke with a Little League official who was at the game. The unidentified umpire then decreed that only English could be spoken.

Mosher said he challenged the ruling, but kept his team on the field after the Little League official said it would stand.

An angry Infante then left the field, which Mosher said demoralized his pitcher and catcher, who speak little English. Methuen lost the game 10-6, though the team remains alive in the tournament.
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

quote:
“It appears the umpire was concerned that the coach or manager may have been using a language other than English ... to communicate potentially ’illegal’ instructions to his players,”

I wonder what will happen when this umpire figures out all this wiping, tugging, and touching by the coach or the manager is also a language other than English that can be used ... to communicate potentially “illegal” instructions to his players.
Just to give the ump a possible benefit of the doubt....

Is it possible that he thought the coach was calling pitches in spanish directly to the pitcher w/o going through the catcher?

I can see how he might want to stop that. However, he should not have forbidden spansih speaking, he should have just told the coach not to call pitches directly.

But I wouldn't be so quick to call him a racist, not knowing the entire situation.
quote:
Just to give the ump a possible benefit of the doubt....

Is it possible that he thought the coach was calling pitches in spanish directly to the pitcher w/o going through the catcher?

I can see how he might want to stop that. However, he should not have forbidden spansih speaking, he should have just told the coach not to call pitches directly.


How is it different if the coach gives signs for pitches or calls them out in Spanish? If the other team picks up the signs, how is that different from learning Spanish? Where in the rulebook do you get the right to tell the team what language they can speak? Is Olympic baseball English only? Where in the rules does it say that coach cannot call out pitches from the dugout in English, Spanish, or Swahili? If he wants to be so stupid as to advertise his pitches in English what rule gives us the right to stop him?

Our local league has formed a team for deaf children. They all communicate in sign language when they play other teams. Am I supposed to ban sign language? This is an absurd discussion.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×