Skip to main content

I posted this on the Let's talk pitching forums a couple days ago. I got some useful information from there but I wanted to know what you guys thought about it..

So I currently play basketball in addition to baseball as a sophomore. My goal is to play college ball and I've heard it really helps if you play two sports. My question is, how much does that help? I have recently become very annoyed with our basketball program as a whole for various reasons. (Being picked on constantly by varsity, poor coaching, just not enjoying it, etc.) If I don't play basketball next year how much will it affect my chances of getting a college scholorship?
Phillipians 4:13
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

TRR:

My son was in your exact situation. He played two years of basketball and decided in his Jr year to drop it. He probably could have done both, but not doing basketball allowed him to focus more on the weight room, his baseball skills, going to showcases and participating in fall baseball events. For him it was the right decision, for you it might not. For the past two years he has been the number one pitcher on his team and he hits in the 3 hole. For him at least, it would have been difficult to achieve this if he was still playing basketball.

An example of this is that his HS basketball team starts their playoff run tonight and they will probably be in the playoffs for another two weeks (they are very good and are expected to potentially win their division) If he was still playing he would have difficulty preparing for the season opener which is two weeks away. That said, he will miss the opportunity of a life time potentially winning a section championship with his basketball team (we hope Wink) .

If you are an elite athlete then it matters little what you do, if you are not then there will always be trade off’s. BTW there are also the academic trade offs and many of his college baseball opportunities are because he worked hard on the field AND in the classroom. BTW he will be a late signer, mostly because of the academic considerations.

College coaches could care less about your other athletic endeavors if you are not good enough to play for them, their only concern is whether they think you can make a positive contribution to their team.

A very wise old timer here gave me the best advice I have received at this site "play both sports until the competition tells you otherwise"

Good luck!
Last edited by BOF
My son played three sports for several years and enjoyed them all except cross country, which he only did to build up his endurance and legs. This year he did CC again and was expected to play basketball. The coach was not happy when he decided not to. He would have enjoyed it, but he was more interested in preparing for baseball. Since he is not good enough to play the other sports at the next level, it also made sense to concentrate on where his bread is buttered.
So unless you have a realistic chance of playing basketball(or any sport) at the type of college you want to go to, it might be time to focus on the one that you can play at the next level.
quote:
Bottom line it's how well you play baseball that matters.

Couldn't agree more.

My son played two sports. During recruiting, the coach encouraged him to play out his senior football season and said that he liked kids who played two sports because it indicated some measure of athleticism he couldn't get just from watching them play baseball.

He also said that the fact my son did not play baseball year round meant that he might have more upside skill-wise than a kid of similar current skill level who had played year round through HS.

That said, I never thought playing two sports was actually a PLUS for baseball recruiting. When my son considered whether or not to continue playing the second sport, we never thought it would negative for his baseball recruiting if he were to quit the second sport.

Bottom line, he has to be able to play baseball. Playing two sports reduces his baseball skill level to some degree, compared to kids who play year round.
There are lots of good reasons for a baseball player to play basketball:

--You love the game.
--You enjoy the competition.
--You want it to be part of your high school memories.
--You know it's your last chance to play basketball competitively.
--You believe the jumping, agility, and conditioning will help your off-season preparation for baseball.


Hoping some college coach down the road will look more favorably on you as a baseball prospect would be a very bad reason.

Multi-sport credentials come into play ONLY if the college-level baseball talent is already apparent AND your achievements in other sports mark you as an usually gifted athlete or physical specimen.

If you're a legitimate college baseball prospect and also an exceptional basketball player, your athletic versatility can become a secondary factor in assessing your potential.

However, because your post indicates that you're playing JV basketball as a sophomore, it's very unlikely that your basketball playing will enter into a college baseball coach's evaluation of you at all.

My advice: play basketball for your own reasons or don't play it all.
3 sports is great if you can do it. Mine do 3, 2, and 3 respectively. 2 is college. Baseball / Basketball and he is a stud at both (in our eyes and many others), but we don't brag about that, it's not polite, especially to other parents. They tend to get a bit lofty in their expectations of their kids and rightly so, they spent a FORTUNE on their kids like we have and did and do. I don't think you can spend enough on your own flesh and blood but the one thing you have to understand is, keep them well grounded but if they have a fire burning within and they are a bit cocky or a lot-a-bit cocky, so be it...only the strong survive. Praying Mantis wives eat their husbands so like I said, only the strong survive. Eat your prey and spit out the bones.
Last edited by switchitter

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×