At Harbor Park. Dean Ali hit a two-run homerun and recorded the final six outs in the Braves 4-3 win.
Original Post
Replies sorted oldest to newest
quote:go
quote:It's a judgment call I understand but (Rule 6-1-3) the pitcher shall go to into the "stretch" motion without interruption and in one continuous motion. He shall come to a complete stop with the ball in both hands in front of his body and in his glove at or below the chin. Note: Failure to come to a complete stop or stopping with both hands above the chin constitutes an illegal pitch or a balk. Ali should have been called on not coming to a complete stop
quote:Originally posted by Base Jones:quote:goquote:It's a judgment call I understand but (Rule 6-1-3) the pitcher shall go to into the "stretch" motion without interruption and in one continuous motion. He shall come to a complete stop with the ball in both hands in front of his body and in his glove at or below the chin. Note: Failure to come to a complete stop or stopping with both hands above the chin constitutes an illegal pitch or a balk. Ali should have been called on not coming to a complete stop
GF, what do you consider a complete stop? I left after the 6th inning, so I cannot comment on what you saw in the 7th, if that is the time you think Ali balked.
Also, I have talked to the home plate umpire and he said that he said nothing even close to "I want to get this over so I can go home."
quote:Originally posted by Base Jones:
GF, the reason I asked is because I hear very often that "the pitcher didn't stop long enough". He either stopped or he didn't. I'm not saying whether he did or didn't, because you were there and I wasn't. And I'm sure that I know the rules much better than you might think I do.
I would tend to side with the umpire on what he said for two reason, (1) he has never worked at Harbor Park, and would have like to stay there all night, and (2) he is a Marine Corp officer with very high standards.
quote:Originally posted by baseballfan10001:
GF, face it. Everyone thinks that the opposing pitcher balked when they know they didn't, just like everyone thinks that their pitcher's 3-2 pitch should have been called strike three even though it was a foot outside... If you were an impartial bystander to this game, like myself, you would have never even think to have thought a balk occured. The only reason this thought came into your head was to make an excuse for you loss. IR won, fair and square, move on, and don't bash the umpire
quote:Originally posted by baseballfan10001:
IR? good guess, but no. you should obviously try to get your facts straight before you go off accusing.. and if its not an "excuse", then why spend time researching and posting a detailed rule and making a big deal of something.... just like " im sure the umpire says he didnt say it", im sure you dont think that your making an excuse.
quote:and
quote:Isnt the rule in place to prevent "quick pitch?"
quote:Originally posted by Indian River Braves:
GF is the 1 that wrote that post about the rules and yes GF i will give ya'll props it was a good gm.we didn't hit like we did vs. nansemond river but ya'll played us tough. and ya'll hit some sharply balls.i dont know if Dean Ali balked or not.yes and i saw where u said ya'll had bunch chances to score and yes ya'll did.
quote:Originally posted by Indian River Braves:
...im not here to brag about indian river.
quote:Originally posted by HR Fan:
...I had IR picked to win the SED outright.
quote:Originally posted by RiverBaseball24:
"reloaded" instead of "rebuilt"