Skip to main content

Saw this in a D1 college game recently:

Runner on first, one out. Soft line drive to shortstop. He moves to catch it, but intentionally drops it, steps on second base and throws over to first for the apparent double play.

I'm not sure what the exact call was, but the umpire said the runner was safe at second base. It could be that he said the ball was really caught, so the batter was out and there was no force at second. But it sure looked like a dropped ball to me - there was no control, it was not dropped on transition, etc.

My question: is there any rule covering this? Or will an umpire "manufacture" a call in order to prevent a cheap double play?

Seemed like a pretty heads up play by the shortstop, though. (He is good - was recently invited to the Team USA trials.)
Last edited {1}
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

A batter is out when an infielder intentionally drops a fair fly ball or line drive, with first, first and second, first and third, or first, second and third base occupied before two are out. The ball is dead and runner or runners shall return to their original base or bases.

The ump in your case got it wrong. The batter should have been out, and the runner returned to first.
quote:
Originally posted by Bulldog 19:
That's a new one for me. It sounds very similar to the Infield Fly rule though.

Simular but not the same. The intentional drop is called with any combo from just first to bases loaded. Also, it can be called on anything in the air, Line drive, bunt or pop-up. It kills the ball, gets the BR out nad returns everyone else.
Infield Fly has to have at least first and second, can't be a line drive or bunt and the ball stays live. This is a normal IF, if you try a intentional drop the rule is the same.
OK guys, here's a twist on this, pointed out to me by my son:

Is this rule for infield plays only? How about a bases-loaded one out fly to short center field?

Assuming the rule only applies to infield plays, what if with bases loaded, one out, the centerfielder intentionally drops the easy fly?

Say runner on first goes halfway... out at second...

Runner on second probably tagging or hanging close to second base takes off when the ball drops - out at third.

Runner scores, but inning is over. Had the centerfielder caught the ball, chances are runner scores anyway and only one out is recorded.

Is this play legal under current rules?

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×