Skip to main content

Appears to be very deserving, for sure. A wonderful player who most everyone agrees played the game the right away, when it was very tough to do.
Backing it up, what I view as a thoughtful piece from Tom Verducci on the vote...and those who didn't make it on his ballot:

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.c...me.ballot/index.html

'You don't have to be a great player to play in the major leagues, you've got to be a good one every day.'

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Congrats to Barry, but should there be a 440 vote difference between him and Bernie Williams?

Larkin Williams
Career Avg Career Avg

Years 19 16
G 2180 162 2076 162
PA 9057 673 9053 706
AB 7937 590 7869 614
R 1329 99 1366 107
H 2340 174 2336 182
2B 441 33 449 35
3B 76 6 55 4
HR 198 15 287 22
RBI 960 71 1257 98
SB 379 28 147 11
CS 77 6 87 7
BB 939 70 1069 83
SO 817 61 1212 95
BA .295 .295 .297 .297
OBP .371 .371 .381 .381
SLG .444 .444 .477 .477
OPS .815 .815 .858 .858
OPS+ 116 116 125 125
TB 3527 262 3756 293
GDP 178 13 223 17
HBP 55 4 39 3
SH 59 4 12 1
SF 67 5 64 5
IBB 66 5 97 8
Comparing an outfielder's numbers to a shortstop's is comparing apples to oranges. Barry was an outstanding offensive shortstop who's defensive value was underrated due to playing the same position at about the same time as the greatest defensive player to ever play the position(Ozzie Smith). Bernie was an excellent offwensive player but his numbers among all time outfielders do not stand out as much since there have been many outfielders with better numbers. Look at the defensive numbers and he was not a highly rrated centerfielder all time either and his arm was below average.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×