Skip to main content

In early June between his sophomore and junior year in HS, JP was hit in the hand on his first AB at the PG Underclass Nationals. While it was really hard to see, the orthopedist believed there was a tiny hairline fracture on that bone that sticks out on the outside of our wrists called the ulnar styloid. He wanted to do an MRI. 

As we all know, that's a big summer for our boys. Our orthopedist specializes in athletes, and knew that. So he told JP it would be OK to keep playing with a light wrist brace -- and that the only risk was having it hit again. So we let him play on. 

He didn't do well.

In spite of his insistence that he was fine, he actually changed his swing. It was subtle, but important. And as he failed, he got inside his own head.

Once healed (it took a good 2-3 months), his coaches worked to get his swing back to normal. But it just wasn't happening. So they adjusted and adjusted and adjusted. Which made things worse because now JP was thinking about his swing all the time. It went from bad to worse, and lasted many months.

Finally, I'd had enough. I stopped all hitting workouts and started taking him to the HS field, where I preached over and over: Just hit the ball. Forget the swing.

Over time, he's finally got his easy swing back and is hitting with confidence.

If I had it to over again, I would:

  • shut him down
  • not send him to so many hitting lessons

I hope if anyone finds themselves in a similar place, they'll think about our experience. And I hope you'll forgive me for posting a couple home run clips from the past two days (and a nice gun from CF) ... because it's been a really long time coming.

 

 

 

Attachments

Videos (1)
JP-Feb
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Glad to hear he's back to health and in action.

I know what you mean as my son had some issues with relatively minor injuries.  One one a jammed/sprained wrist and another over shinsplints.  It was in his college sophomore year and he was a key starter and they just kept playing him without really giving him any rest, though they did try a few therapeutic things outside of games and practices that just didn't work.  Rest is what he really needed, but it seemed he was encouraged to "man up" and work through it.  It didn't work and his sophomore year ended up being one of his worst seasons ever.  

Your example of getting the hitting lessons to correct a hitting issue again illustrates to me that most of the time (like 95%) it's really not a mechanical issues, it's a mental one.  A hitter putting so much mechanical issues into their mind can really screw up a good swing. . . aside from some kind of injury hindrance.  

Yes. MENTAL, Truman!

I posted this because I was talking to a player's grandfather this weekend. His grandson is a stud. Heading to D1. He's a switch hitter. He has a hamstring injury -- and is hitting left against lefties. His grandfather (who knows a ton about baseball) said he's seeing changes in the swing, and it ain't good.

My son played through an injury last year the specialist said couldn't get any worse. He's missing this season. Now I just want him to walk properly and be able to run the rest of his life. He accepts baseball is over. He fears not being able to snowboard and play pickup basketball as an adult.

Last edited by RJM
RJM posted:

My son played through an injury last year the specialist said couldn't get any worse. He's missing this season. Now I just want him to walk properly and be able to run the rest of his life. He accepts baseball is over. He fears not being able to snowboard and play pickup basketball as an adult.

Always sad to hear that baseball is over . . .particularly when it'd due to some injury.   Hope he can still play those sports he loves.  I feel lucky to have been able to play basketball up to age 55 (long time ago).  Then I started to listen to my body that was telling me I shouldn't be playing with these 30-somethings any longer.   I don't know how nor enjoy playing basketball except at full tilt, so that was the end of that.  Now I find other things that give me just as much joy . . . like coaching when I can.  And I still like having a catch with my son when he's around and soak my bruised glove hand and fingers afterwards.    

Wishing the best for your son. 

Last edited by Truman

Thanks. I played basketball with the thirty somethings until I had a dissection and four stokes three years ago. Basically I'm back in good health. But I can't do spin moves on the basketball court without losing balance. I wanted to ski for the first time in three years this winter. I just wanted to see if I could handle intermediate sloped this year. There's no snow. What few storms we've had went out to sea instead north. I'm not attemting my return on bare spots and man made ice. It has been warm enough a few days to bike.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×