Skip to main content

On the Illinois forum there is an interesting and sometimes heated discussion about putting together an 18U team of IL players to play a "national" schedule against top 18U teams. Some folks say there is no way a team from IL could compete with the warm weather teams.

A look at the 2004 roster of one "national" team, the Midland Redskins, suggests that it is possible for cold weather players to compete on the national level.

Here's a breakdown of the home states of the top ten position players and top six pitchers from the twenty-player Connie Mack WS roster.

Position players: OH-3, FL-2, IN, IL, GA, VA, NC-1 each.
Pitchers: OH - 2, FL, PA, NH, Can.- 1 each.

Five of ten position players were from cold weather states. Five of six pitchers were from cold weather states.

Something to think about.
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

In this day and age I don't think geography makes much difference. I don't think there is any doubt that a team from the Midwest can compete on the national level. Many already do. With today's awareness of training methods, and with indoor facilities cropping up everywhere, any player from any area can develop his talents. I think many Northern players migrate south to play college baseball; my guess is to take advantage of the extended baseball season and better facilities?
Fungo
04Parent. Thanks for info on the site. It must have been 79 that I was thinking of. Looking at the site there are quite a few northern teams that have won the Connie Mack World Series over the years proving that teams from the north can have have competed well at the national level.

I have always considered the Connie Mack World Series to be the #1 national baseball event for the 18 year old age group.
Having a son who grew up in Chicago, and now plays JUCO baseball in AZ, I will tell you that the kids from the warmer area's don't work at the game as hard as the players from the "cold" area's. They aren't as fundementally sound and they complain about the weather MORE. He loves that he is outside in shorts and a t-shirt...on a field in January..but he has called out a team mate or two for not wanting it bad enough or not working hard enough to make a change.
I have heard coaches there say that they would take a kid from a cold climate over one from a warm climate, all things being equal...because the cold climate kid will out work and out hustle the warm climate kid....and I agree with that. I am not saying that all warm climate kids are lazy...but I think you you were to look at the players...day in and day out...you'd see the difference. The only advantage the warm weather players have is that they can play more...but work less on fundementals

Just my opinion from what I have seen over the last year
Almost every year, the state of Illinois ranks fourth behind the "Big Three" of Florida, Texas, and California in the number of players that are drafted. Granted that is only one northern state but it shows that there is talent.

I agree with the previous posts that say that Illinois kids seem to want it a bit more when they come to southern schools. The northern kids I know who play in the south all are praised by their coaches for their level of committment and work habits. Sometimes those from the south take for granted the fact that it is 60 degrees in March.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×