Skip to main content

I'll probably be filleted for these comments.

 

The MLB HR Derby is a snooze alert borefest... after round 1.

 

I would personally love see a more well rounded exhibition of skills.  

 

This might include...

- 1 Round of HR Derby

- Fastest man competition

- Strongest arm.

- Most accurate arm (hit targets from distance)

- Most range by OF & IF

- Quickest hands comp.

- Most accurate bat (like "HORSE" for hitters)

 

All of these things could be done in the same amount of time as 1 long boring HR Derby.

 

Just my 2 cents.

 

Rich

www.PlayInSchool.com/bus_tour

 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I did not watch the HR Derby this year, but my big issue with the All Star Game is the proliferation of relief pitchers that make the squad.  Yes, I understand the game is evolving, and relief pitchers are more important than ever, but, I believe this year's AL All Star roster has more relief pitchers than starting pitchers.  Part of this may be due to the rule that all teams must have at least one All Star representative (maybe time to drop this?  Let's just have the best players?) But, why does the AL roster need to contain 5 closers? (Doolittle, Holland, Perkins, Rodney and Uehara) Meanwhile, Chris Sale and Garret Richards, who have posted absurd and outstanding numbers, respectively, as starters, are relegated to the "last player fan vote", with Richards not getting a nod. Chris Sale would have a sub 2 ERA were it not for Mike Trout reaching down and poking a grand salami about a month ago on a completely nasty pitch down and out of the zone.....Starters with outstanding numbers are always more deserving, in my mind, than virtually any reliever - but that's just me. 

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×