Skip to main content

While being a long time reader of the board I rarely if ever post. However, I have a situation that I could use some help with. My son is a junior this year at a very large high school in the Southeast. As a freshman, we were not sure he would even make the freshman team. He played every inning of every game on the freshman team. As a sophomore, same thing for JV. After his JV season he would have been the number two catcher on the varsity summer team. The number one catcher, who is the same grade and started as a freshman on varsity, injured himself the day before summer ball started. Son caught every inning of every game all summer including 2 WWBA tournaments. Did quite well. To be clear, he is not the quality player as the number one catcher, who is getting a ton of attention from many Div. 1 schools. Son decided last month that he does not want to play this spring. Lots of reasons, grades, time commitment, playing time, girlfriend ect, doesn’t like coach, lazy teen ager. (the last two I threw in) However, coaches do not seem to want to take no as an answer. Since notifying coach of his decision he is getting pretty heavy pressure from the coaching staff to reconsider. It is also important to note the son does want to play with his buddies (who have dropped along the way) rec ball in the spring.

Curious as to whether any of you have been in this situation and could use some direction. How can you get a head strong 17 year old to see he may be making a mistake he will regret. If his decision stands, how do you tell the coaches to back off? What would the motivation of the coaching staff to pursue so aggressively a, at best, bit role player for the team? It is not a numbers thing as turnout for tryouts is always very heavy.
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

The coaches job is to field the best team he can at the same time caring for his players, your sons job is to do what's best for him. The coach seems to be putting the pressure on. If I were him I do the same until convinced this is what the player wants, then drop it. The last thing you want is a player on the team who doesn't want to be there.

Many will feel that the coach is being "over bearing", but I feel that HS students sometimes make hasty decisions that are not completely thought out, or based on poor advise from outside sources. A good "players coach" will have a feel for that "line of demarkation".
I don't have direct experience in this area however I think it is good that the coaches are interested in keeping your son involved, it is a credit to them and to your son that they value his participation.

In the end there is a time where everyone stops playing baseball; for some it is in rec league and for some much later. If it were my son I would advise him to think it through weigh out the positive and negative aspects of the decision and allow him to explain to the coaches. Stay out of it other than the one on one discussion with him. Whatever way it goes it will make him a better person for having to weigh out a decision, talk it through with other adults, and then have to live with the consequences, good, bad or indifferent.
If your son is not interested now, how would he ever play college ball ? This may be a good decision by your son and as stated he will have to live with the consequences. There have been sevreal threads on this subject. It is a common situation. If BB is not enough to keep him involved maybe he should quit. If my son showed the slightest disinterest I would have probably pulled the plug on BB after having a chat with him.
I had the most talented, athletic group of kids I had ever coached (basketball) all through their middle school years. When they were in 7th grade, I gave them all pictures of the Peoria Fieldhouse, where the state championship basketball games are played and told them that they could play there if they wanted it bad enough.

As they came up through HS, they began dropping out of basketball, mostly to play football. When I would hear that one of them was considering dropping, I would make it a point to have a conversation with them to listen to their reasons. At the end of each conversation, I would tell them the same thing...they would never regret the decision to have played HS basketball, but they may regret the decision not to. It never swayed one player to continue.

That group of kids did win the state championship...in football in 2007.

I've never been succesful in swaying a kid back towards a sport, not even my own. My oldest now tells me he regrets not continuing in HS football.
Last edited by CPLZ
I think many players as they approach senior year make this decision. They want to hang out and enjoy their senior year.If they dont think they are going to go on they just do not want the time committment. I would want my son to have a job though if not playing asport. They need to have some accountability and not too much free time.

Add Reply

Post
.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×