Hey AntsDad,
I’m afraid you won’t like my position on this. I was VERY guilty as an OF player. So is Cabbage. As you said, so are most OF’s.
Of course we teach our IF’s to field the ball with their hands. So their gloves have to be “part of” their hands. For an OF, the glove is more of an extension of the hand. An IF typically catches the ball near where the palm meets the fingers with the thought of using their hands. An OF typically catches the ball at or near the fingertips either in the web or at the junction of the web and pocket. Their thought is to clamp or pinch the glove with their thumb and pinky/ring finger as the levers. So, an IF may feel more comfortable using more of the pocket and, thus, more hand in the glove. Most OF’s are able to work their glove easier with the base of the palm partially out of the glove. Searching for the right terminology, I consulted with Cabbage – “It’s easier to squeeze”. Brilliant.
My terminology – I can pinch the glove more effectively with the base of my palm well out of the glove so that I get less interference from the heel of the glove.
This also gives the OF the feeling of maximum reach when tracking down fly balls and line drives at full speed as well as more reach when running through a roller on a do-or-die. No time to break down and field it like an IF.
More E's? Yeah, possibly if the OF allows laziness and lack of focus due to the extra length. I think it is just like an NHL defenseman with a longer stick though. They can be amazingly precise when they are in tune with their longer stick.
My test for my players...
..slow rollers in deep grass – the OF must be able to run through those and pick the ball with their glove. If they can’t, they need more control of the glove, whether it be getting more hand in the glove or a glove that is tighter and/or more cupped at the end. That’s also why I don’t like flared-tip gloves for OF. It may be OK on a perfectly groomed MLB turf but not for the typical HS grass.
OP, sorry for the slight diversion. It is another interesting topic, though.