My son had sent out several emails to schools he was interested in. Very moderate responses, he was small and not throwing hard and didn't have much to offer at the time. His HS V coach liked him a lot. Enough to bring him up as a frosh for defense. The V Coach left the school the next year for the local JUCO program. He had my son attend their winter workout camp and introduced him to the HC of the program. He had a less than stellar outing at the showcase and heard crickets after that.
Two summers later, he plays on a good summer team and does very well. Attends the PG SE Top Prospect showcase and gets immediate attention form a new PC at low level D1 in South Carolina. Visits and everything goes great. Lots of back and forth talk but no actual offer due to not being able to get in front of the HC.....all is good because turns out this PC left before the season started!
Gets invited to the local JUCO for a workout, throws a horrible bullpen, but the coaches know he has great offspeed stuff....tells him they'll think about it and that they don't usually offer the local guys much. Crickets again. Then comes Jupiter. I spot the entire JUCO Staff there, they come up to me and we chat. They say they are there to see him throw one particular pitch, the good ole CB, in a game situation. Son threw well and as the coaches are leaving they stop by to talk to me, after talking to my son. Told me that they told him they would have a package offer put together by the end of the week. Done deal after that.
This was the school I was realistically targeting since he entered HS. m Of course he had higher aspirations, but settled for being able to say he was recruited by a D! school( I launched an exhaustive campaign against the D1 fever very early on...lol). But, through his hard work he got his scholly and the opportunity to continue to play.
So, don't write anything off after a bad performance, anything is possible.