Skip to main content

Runner on first and third two outs runner from first going on pitch high bouncer over pitcher ss coming across for difficult play PU rolls out to start down 1st base line seeing there is going to be hard play rolls toward third base keeping eye on first for swipe tag or pull. Throws brings 1B off bag up line toward home makes swipe tag that U1 can not see. By this time PU is ten feet fair and and about 20 feet toward third. U1 appeals to home and PU makes the out call offensive coach argues that PU can not make that call from that position. Where should PU have been?
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

The PU has to read the play and decide is the ball going to first or coming home. If he thinks it's going to first, he is going to go up the first base line just like there was no R3 but he is going to glance back to see if he is advancing. If R3 is coming home, the PU doesn't want to move too far up the line because there may be a throwback.
Now in your OP he moved up the third base line, why I'm not sure, but if he has a look when the BU comes to him then he can certainly make a call. Now, he shouldn't call the runner safe or out, that's the BU's job, but instead give the BU what information he has and let the BU cange or not change his call.
Also, the manager gets NO SAY in umpire mechanics, NONE! That discussion is going to met with a quick, go to the dugout coach. If he persists it will lead to an early day for him. They can ask about what we saw or how we are enforcing a rule. Umpire mechanics are nothing he knows about, nor something he can discuss.
What I was taught at proschool a little over ten years ago:

PU would clear the catcher, keeping chest to ball and would establish a position in foul territory off the third base line that gave him a view of the pulled foot, swipe tag. With R3 we were taught not to drift up the first base line unless there was a fair/foul call to be made. Even then, the drift would be no more than three or four steps.

Too many things can wrong quickly and you end up with a runner scoring behind your back or getting in the way of a throw to home.

Additionally, Jim now teaches that even though this is not a hit to the outfield, PU still has any play on R1 at third, should one develop from a series of bad throws, or sh!tty baserunning.
Last edited by Jimmy03

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×