I teach my first baseman to stay at 1B with a runner on 1B. The Pitcher backs up the Catcher and the Shortstop gets in behind the Third Baseman. I teach if the runner on 1B advances to 2B as the pickle is being executed between 3B and Home then the First Baseman should go get in it with the Pitcher and Catcher. I leave the First Baseman at 1B, because a bad runner of a runner with a brain freeze may get hung up between 1B and 2B after the play is completed between 3B and Home, and we may have a pickle with the First Baseman being at 1B and the Second Baseman having 2B (Shortstop will hustle over, but he was in pickle between 3B and Home). Any thoughts or ideas would be appreciated. Thank you.
Original Post