Skip to main content

Our league (as I would assume most others) has a 'slide or avoid' rule to protect the kids from injury (Pony 13/14).
I had a situation the other night with a play at home. Runner at 3rd was sent home on a batted ball, and the thow to home was a bit off target. The throw pulled the catcher down the 3rd base line about 5-10 ft.He was set to catch the throw at the same time my runner would be at the catchers position.It was just a bit to far for him to initiate an effective slide. If the 'slide or avoid' rule were not in effect, and he chose to do so, he could have run the catcher over and easily scored, as the ball arrived at the same time as the collision would have (if anything, the runner would have it a fraction before the ball).

He elected (wisely) to slide early between the catcher's legs. He came up about 2 feet short of home.

The result is inconsequential, as the catcher dropped the ball anyway, and the runner just scooted forward and touched home safely.

What should be the correct course of action for the runner to do here to (a) be safe (b) be legal, and (c) SCORE?

And, of course, what would be the possible rulings or outcomes?
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

a question that has bugged me for a long long time. this happened in a Dixie Youth baseball game 8 or 9 years ago. I was one third base and the ball got pass the catcher, I broke for home trying to score as I was sliding into home the catcher dives at me. To me it looked like he was coming straight at my head, me being about 2 inches shorter and 20 pounds lighter than the catcher. My pure reactions led me to throw my arms up to try and guard my face. Since it has been so long I forget whether there was an actual collision or not or whether I scored but after the play the other teams coach (who son happened to be the catcher) came out and made a big fuse about me "throwing elbows" at his son...the umpire then warned me that if I did it again he would throw me out of the game. Was I wrong in trying to protect myself?
Any time we have a collision, it is the umpire who has to judge intent....What may very well have been your attempt to protect yourself, may have been viewed as an attempt to make malicous contact by the umpire .....

At the age group you were in at the time, I would definately lean towards understanding of your need to protect yourself, but I would also have warned you afterwards that you could be ejected for doing it if the umpire deemed it done on purpose or repeatedly.....
Last edited by piaa_ump

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×