Skip to main content

I know we've debated wood vs. metal ad nauseum. But this is part of a letter I just got from Little League Int'. I know we won't all agree on which bat is "safer" however we all have to acknowledge how ridiculous it would be to fine children for playing in the back yard (or anywhere for that matter) with an aluminum bat.

"In case you haven’t heard, the New York City Council voted to ban the use of aluminum bats for all high school games played in the City. Now, similar legislation could find its way to Illinois – legislation that would ban all non-wood bats from being used in all Little League games, including softball, throughout the state.

What concerns me most is that this bill in Illinois would fine children playing with a non-wood bat $250 for a first offense and $500 for a second offense. This would even include if a child played in a pick-up sandlot game.

After hearing this news, I contacted the office of Illinois Representative Robert Molaro, who is sponsoring the bill. His Chief of Staff told me that he might consider a different version of the bill after hearing the facts I presented him.

I was encouraged by the discussion; however we have not received any confirmation of a revised bill and feel we cannot wait longer to make you aware of this matter.

At Little League, nothing is more important to us than child safety and I can report to you that a ban on aluminum bats is not necessary. It will harm our game and make it less enjoyable for the millions of children who safely play the game today, just as it has been safely played for the last forty years.

Little League Baseball has joined a coalition of parents, coaches and bat makers to oppose this unnecessary ban.

The Coalition is named “Don’t Take My Bat Away” and I urge you to join so that we can have a large voice to fight a potential bat ban in Illinois.

Please log onto their website, www.DTMBA.com, and carefully review the facts and the science behind Little League’s decision to support the safe use of both wood and aluminum bats."
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

You can hardly get an game offical to check a questionable bat much less put it on the police force.

We have a neighboring town that just made it against the law punishable by fine and/or time for the kids wearing their pants baggy. While I don't like that fashion statement do we really need to turn hard working police officers into fashion cops?

Aren't our police officers over worked and underpaid enough without adding checking bats and pants to their daily routine???
quote:
we are going to have to throw the bags of tea overboard AGAIN!
so ya call your lawmakers "teabags" in Il??

I can see it now ...

a couple dozen 10 yr olds scattering from the vacant lot as the "bat police" show up -
and the hitter running for the woods, bat in hand screaming "don't taser me bro"!!
Last edited by Bee>
Okay bballdad, semantics. I understand.

However, picture this, my kids are the ball diamond about two blocks from my house. They're playing a little pickup game with Al bats. Maybe a little homerun derby.

So the bat police show up. What are they going to do? How will they know who to fine for this illegal activity? They'll have to accost my children to determine who their deadbeat parents are.

Nice country we live in where children will live in fear while playing America's Pastime. All because some a-hole do gooder politician thinks he's going to save the world from the evils of Al bats.

Message to our politicians: You are already in my life way too much. Stay the hell out!
95TH GENERAL ASSEMBLY
State of Illinois
2007 and 2008HB4140


Introduced , by Rep. Robert S. Molaro


SYNOPSIS AS INTRODUCED:


720 ILCS 150/5.2 new


Amends the Wrongs to Children Act. Provides that it is unlawful for any coach, parent, teacher, or other person to knowingly allow the use of an aluminum bat during a recreational baseball or softball game in which a person under the age of 13 is a participant. Provides that a violation is a petty offense and is punishable by a fine of $250 for a first offense and $500 for a second or subsequent offense. Effective immediately.



LRB095 13687 HLH 39520 b








A BILL FOR





HB4140 LRB095 13687 HLH 39520 b



1 AN ACT concerning safety.

2 Be it enacted by the People of the State of Illinois,
3 represented in the General Assembly:

4 Section 5. The Wrongs to Children Act is amended by adding
5 Section 5.2 as follows:

6 (720 ILCS 150/5.2 new)
7 Sec. 5.2. Use of aluminum bats prohibited. It is unlawful
8 for any coach, parent, teacher, or other person to knowingly
9 allow the use of an aluminum bat during a recreational baseball
10 or softball game in which a person under the age of 13 is a
11 participant. Any violation of this Section is a petty offense
12 and is punishable by a fine of $250 for a first offense and
13 $500 for a second or subsequent offense.

14 Section 99. Effective date. This Act takes effect upon
15 becoming law.

What about the ball? How can you impose a bat law without stipulating the ball that is used? Respectfully, as a lawmaker there are certainly issues regarding the quality of life for the less fortunate to focus on.
I agree it is a stupid law. I don't think it can or should be enforced. I don't think it will pass because it is poorly written.

There IS a substantive difference, not a stricktly semantic one, about charging the fine to children or adults. I don't believe in the law, but I don't think police will be going to parks and interrigating children to discover which parents to fine. And I agree people should let their appropriate legislative rep know what they think about it.
tough topic, I remember when I was coaching my son at 10 we were in a bring it swing it tournament and we had a big and I mean big barrel bat my kid was 5'9" 145lb's at this age always one of the bigger kids. I still remember worrying about him hitting a shot back at the pitcher or third baseman. I did take it out of his hands at some point the thing looked like one of those wiffle ball bats. I would rather watch a game with metal bats at the high school age, they should probably look at the barrel size with the young kids

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×