quote:
Originally posted by Ling:
redbird, I meant makeup in the context of purely size. I know makeup means much more that. My bad. I heard that a D1 college just signed a 5'8" catcher. Either you are a player or not, and pure size doesn't matter. Read Moneyball. What is very interesting from that book is that a ton of the college kids discussed in that book, are playing BL ball, or are solid, solid contributors on thier ML teams. I think a lot of people believed Swisher would make it, but again its amazing how many others are in the bigs. Later on.
You heard about the 5'8" catcher from a wacko on HSBBWEB that lives in his mom's basement. Don't believe everything you read, especially from your above source.
Physical size and strength are important. Not many starters in MLB are less than 6'2". If so, they have great stuff. Size is not a tool but an asset. If there is a 5'10" guy and a 6'2" guy with similar stuff, everyone I know would take the bigger guy.
I still don't see your point other than "either you are a player or you are not". (With which I agree).