Gingerbread Man,
I happen to think you’re pretty much right on target too, but I can tell you haven’t had to deal a whole lot with SoCal, Tx, or Fl people.
I’m here in central NorCal where we have roughly 150-200 schools playing baseball in 7 different divisions. Our school is in the large school division, and this season played 31 games agains18 different teams, 4 of which were DII schools, 1 a DIII school, 1 a DIV school, and 1 from another state that I think was a big school.
In all those games, and some were against eventual league or section winners, there’s no way we saw more than 5 kids who could touch 90. 1 is a legit 90 cruiser, but the other heat bringers were much like the kid on our team who did it. As a Jr he occasionally touched 90 or 91, but this season with anywhere from 2 to 12 guns on him, every time he pitched, he didn’t throw any harder, and in fact was much more erratic and didn’t pitch nearly as well as he did last year.
Most of the other top arms had lots of eyeballs on them, but the division they played in had a lot to do with how dominating they were.
10 of 47 hits were xbh hits. 64 K’s out of 250 batters. Meanwhile, another kid, virtually the same size, 6’5”/190 and throwing virtually the same velocity, but on a DVI championship team faced 84 batters, only 2 of the 18 hits he gave up were XBHs, and he struck out 48 of the 84 batters he faced. Meanwhile, the kid who was by far the hardest thrower in the area, face 210 batters, gave up 39 hits, 5 doubles, and struck out 70 batters.
Its interesting to look at those numbers in terms of relations.
Batters per K.
Our pitcher – 1 per 3.9 batters
The DVI pitcher – 1 per 1.75 batters
The stud – 1 per 3 batters.
So what happens is, a very skewed sense of what’s going on can take place. In fact, what usually happens is, the best hitters don’t fare as well against “pitchers”. FI, we have a kid on our team who hits 84-85 on a good pitch, but he’s a pitcher. He’s struck out the same number of batters as the other kid on our team, but he’s done it against 8 fewer batters, and against far superior competition.
In short, you’re 100% correct. The reason more flame throwers come from places like Ca, Tx, or Fl, is simply because they have more players. And also, how “dominant” any particular pitcher looks, has much more to do with who he’s throwing against than how hard he throws.