Three years ago, per Baseball America: Some college baseball players who first set foot onto a campus in 2018 could still be playing college baseball in 2025 as seventh-year seniors thanks to Red Shirt rules and the NCAA granting COVID-19 eligibility relief in 2020 and 2021 at some levels.
So, did it happen? Anyone know of anyone who was a 2018 High School graduate who is still playing college baseball now?
Replies sorted oldest to newest
https://byucougars.com/sports/.../player/brett-hansen
He started college later due to his mission trip, but graduated 2018 and us currently a RS-Junior.
Maybe we shouldn't call out anyone by name on this one?
Yes.
I checked two teams with transfer-heavy rosters and found 3 guys.
https://charlotte49ers.com/spo...ter/tony-rossi/11159
https://bluehens.com/sports/ba.../bryce-greenly/27935
A handful of graduate transfers who were Ivy undergrads fit this bill.
As interesting would be an analysis of College Freshman, who did not make a roster due to the eligibly relief.
This would be tough to quantify due to the subjectivity, so maybe just a show of hands from HSBBW participants knowledge of players in their sphere who didn't make the cut because of roster relief.
Aaliyah Jordan, softball player, was 7 years at UCLA
2017 medical redshirt
2018 played
2019 played
2020 Covid
2021 played
2022 medical redshirt
2023 played
@BaseballBUDDY posted:As interesting would be an analysis of College Freshman, who did not make a roster due to the eligibly relief.
This would be tough to quantify due to the subjectivity, so maybe just a show of hands from HSBBW participants knowledge of players in their sphere who didn't make the cut because of roster relief.
Know of 2 that were told there was no room on the roster just before starting their Fr years. They were both recommended to JUCOs by their committed schools. One returned to the school that committed them after JUCO, the other ended up at a different D1 school.
If that is what you are talking about.
@Francis7 posted:Maybe we shouldn't call out anyone by name on this one?
It’s not a bad thing? It’s allowed….info is on the bios. I’m sure there are more than a few, just happen to know of this one. He also had a TJ.
Our 2021 roster had 8 graduate students that would not have been there without COVID relief. I think 5 from the freshman class either left by Christmas or didn’t make the roster.
@baseballhs posted:https://byucougars.com/sports/.../player/brett-hansen
He started college later due to his mission trip, but graduated 2018 and is currently a RS-Junior.
Mormons doing two year missions after freshman or soph year is very normal. They return and don’t graduate until they’re 24 or 25. Often their missions show them there’s a lot more to life than sports and they don’t play when they return.
A friend decided he was so far from college baseball shape after two years in South America he returned to BYU, got married and finished school.
Sean clifford broke a lot of PSU records, most yards, tds what not. I sure hope he would have, he played for 6 years compared to everyone else. Just dumb.....
I don’t like seeing players who received almost five years of playing time rewriting their school or conference record books. Some guys are quality college talent but not serious pro prospects. They played five years and accumulated stats.
Son's team had a six year senior. Great kid and good team leader as a catcher. He got a covid year and somehow a medical red-shirt (min games played was covid year at 5). He just loved the game and basically said, hey, if they want to give me another year, I'm back.
Honestly, I think NCAA should rethink eligibility, if it were up to me I'd give everyone 5 years, thinking in terms of 4 undergrad years and one grad year, regardless of how you use them, with 5 being the max, medical redshirt or not.
Well, technically, they get 5 years to play 4 seasons. I think if you gave them 5 in 5 then it's blocking the pipeline?
My son was a 2019 high school grad and is in his 5th year with the only redshirt being the Covid year. He is in his 2nd year at his 2nd D1 and was not used in the 3 years at the first one. Was a Saturday starter last year with 72 ip so I guess had he received a redshirt as a freshman ( which he should’ve based on innings) I suppose he would be in position for a 6th. Knowing what he went thru I don’t see anything wrong with it. He is on his 4th PC in 5 years so it’s not only the kids and the portal making things happen
@Francis7 posted:Well, technically, they get 5 years to play 4 seasons. I think if you gave them 5 in 5 then it's blocking the pipeline?
I may not be thinking about this right, but isn't It only blocking the pipeline now because they only gave the extra year to those that were already in college and nobody else.
My thought about 5 was two-fold, 1 having the option of an almost automatic red-shirt for freshman without worrying about if you practiced with the team or played one inning and lose a full year or 2. about giving all players a chance to play 1 year as a grad student, the opportunity to take one last year of potentially playing D1 or move up levels of D1 for one shot. Or for those close to draft-able, that one last Post Grad year.... But this also allows a student to finish their degree at one school and not have to transfer to play at a higher level.
This just popped into my head because of all the DIII players in the NE that now are having an opportunity to play D1 as a grad student because they had that 5th year, but that opportunity won't exists for anyone else who wasn't affected by covid.
