Skip to main content

Now that most of you here are either in the midst of or beyond HS ball, allow me to show you what I think may be a huge part of many of the problems baseball has, especially safety, that being the rush to FAME AND GLORY

The following is an excerpt from a post a dad looking for answers posted on a bulletin board, and an excerpt from an answer from someone who’s a very respected baseball coach/teacher/guru.

While I have no problem with a 12YO monkeying around with the big boys in a “pick up” environment, allowing them to actually practice with a JV HS team is a different matter entirely. What I don’t know is if this is one of those schools with a MS programs and no Fr program which might make the next logical step for school ball the JV team.

That would throw a different light on it, but I’d still be very much bothered by putting a 12YO, no matter how physically mature, in with a bunch of boys ranging from 14 to 18, and who just might not appreciate a “twerp” in their midst.

Q: My son is only 12 years old and has been invited to start working out with the JV/HS team. Since he loves the game of baseball and has been graced by the man upstairs with some good skills for his age I was wondering if he is setting himself up for an early burn out.

A: He is being offered the opportunity to learn from the experience of practicing on the big field with big boys. I suspect it will be a watershed moment in his baseball career. It will rocket him past his peers.
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I think that a clear picture of what type of school this is, is very important in order to keep things in perspective. This could easily be a relatively small private school where the middle school and high school are ajoined. Many of these smaller schools can barely fill a roster with players that can throw and catch, much less hit!
That being said, I can't imagine a 12 year old playing with our JV team. Any program that is above a 1A or 2A should be no place for a 12 year old.
I guess I don't see the big deal. My son was fortunate enough to hang out with a D-I college team when he was 10 years old...
...and coach actually put him at 2B during infield/outfield practice one day. The SS was...
...now MLB player Ty Wigginton.

The work habits and respect for the game helped him...
...and I suspect even hanging out with kids 2-3 years older will help your son (just be ready for some new words he may learn).
So far, you’ve all had thoughts and perspective that I can understand, if not agree with. But what I just can’t wrap my brain around is, I’ve never seen nor heard of a HS coach who ever had enough time to work with his players. So, what motivation would he have to take what little time he has to develop the players already on the team, and give it to a kid, who except for a very few extraordinary circumstances, wouldn’t be able to help the team for at least 2 years.

Except for the extraordinary circumstances such as Floridafan mentioned, I’m guessing its much more of a thing where someone’s kid is getting a favor because the coach somehow “owes” dad. I don’t mean that in necessarily a bad way, but I can’t imagine every 12YO in town would be able to get that same thing.

My son’s JUCO coach always had his son practicing with the team, and every once in a while a couple of his pals would be there too. And I’ve seen other coaches of teams where they let their kids who definitely belonged in leagues much lower, allow their kids to work out with the team. That’s OK because its up to the HC what goes on. But to be draggin’ kids off the street with no ties whatsoever to the team just seems wrong to me.
Insurance/liability issues? What if the kid got hurt or hurt someone else?

How about medical clearance? All the HS kids have it, but the 12 year old is not cleared with the District.

Really doubt that practicing with a JV team will "rocket" anyone past anyone. All it really does is take someone's reps and tick the other players off...

Much better off picking a top travel team or local baseball coach/clinic or exercise guru to make the kid stronger or work on his tools.

Is this kid as big as the 14 year olds? Can he throw as hard? Run as fast? Are his catching skills as good? If he really can hit JV pitching, keep up on the bases, and catch as well, then this JV team must really be bad. How can practicing with a bad JV team improve anything, except having him learn some words and behavior that Dad won't necessarily approve of?

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×