Rewording question because people are having trouble understanding it.
Before I go into the details here is the premise of the argument if someone says "do you want to take an infield/outfield on the field?" during warmups before a game where would you go? The two choices are to the outfield where you do a infield/outfield, or to your normal game position on the field. The answer should solely be based on how the question was phrased.
I got into this debate with my friend because he stated that he would go to his game position because that is what he thought the coach meant, but I thought that the coach meant he wanted us to take infield outfield in the outfield because that is where we normally go. How would you respond?
EDIT: If this is confusing in any way please leave a comment I would love to clarify