This May Sound Odd But The Best Glove For The Job Is no bigger then 11-1/2. Other gloves are too big. While they may snag that ball deep down the line on the hop because of how big it is, are u really gonna throw him out, if so great, but chances are not. I'd go with a smaller glove that you can get the glove out of quicker. I'm mainly a SS,3rd,2nd kind of guy and I use a pro preffered "J" Series 11-1/4. I also own a Mizuno Chipper Classic 11-3/4, it can be used but i think it's just a little too big for the infield i tend to use that out in the outfield more.
GOOD LUCK and make sure to try the gloves on
TRY HERE FOR THE "J" Series but i would go try on a regular one first