Not necessarily the best college pitchers but two of the best pitched college games I have seen:
1. Jeremy Guthrie from Stanford: 13 inning 3-2 win against Fullerton in the Regionals his junior year. Pitch count...
2. Mike Frost from Trinity University who pitched a complete game win in a 2002 West Region elimination game...about 8 hours of grieving after learning his pitching coach and dear friend died during the night in his sleep. Remarkable and unforgettable.