Championship Ring or Hall of Fame Ring?

Since I'm a ring collector and look at it from that standpoint, I'd have to say the HOF ring would be more valuable and desired from a collector's point of view.

The HOF ring isn't very appealing asthetically though. The team rings are much nicer.

From a players perspective, I think they would prefer the HOF ring as that is an individual career accomplishment rather than a team accomplishment that they contributed to over the course of a season. Of course if you have been a Yankee player for the past 10 years or so, you have 6 rings to wear from that period, 4 WS Championships and 2 American League Championships. That's alot of bling as the Yankees rings are loaded with diamonds. Do 6 rings outweigh the one?

If I'm a player, I'll take the HOF over a championship ring.

very very tough question.hof says great career,earned over a lifetime.but your old.

championship earned with a team over a season.unforgetable memorys with a team.and a lifetime to tell everyone.i'd have to say the championship, if its world champions.just league champs i'd go hof.

Hall of Fame....

You were the best of the best.

How can you beat that?

I saw Truck Robinson at the golf course I worked at. He was using the roof of his golf cart for a desk adding up his scorecard. He is very tall.

I thought that you played the game to win a World Series? If you do your best the individual honors will come if they are deserved. Give me a World Championship!!!!!!!!