Skip to main content

Today I have been listening to a number of players who were coached by Bill Walsh. Universally, when asked, they attribute their success to Bill Walsh's unique ability to identify their strengths as a player and to game coach to those strengths through schemes and plays.
When our son was scouted in high school and for professional ball, he was always lucky to find a coach or scout who saw something but, frankly, they seemed to be in the minority.
CD's son is a very good example of a rather "lightly" recruited player who has blossomed to be a core part of a now top 25 college program.
When ours did play in college, summer wood bat leagues, and then professionally, he did more than fine. In fact, in professional ball, coaches were amongst his biggest supporters in the organization where others often control player personnel decisions.
With Bill Walsh as a background, do others believe baseball players be successful with certain coaches in college because of their approach and "scheme" of coaching baseball and coaching games. Or, does baseball expose your "weaknesses" in ways good coaches cannot overcome?.
Is the Bill Walsh approach unique to a sport like football?
While I don't mean to single out CD's son, I think players like Tyler are a wonderful focus for the question. Would he have been successful at any DI program or is there something about his college coaching staff that permits his strengths to dominate over perceived weaknesses in college baseball and beyond?

'You don't have to be a great player to play in the major leagues, you've got to be a good one every day.'

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

CD - I believe you are right on the mark when you say confidence is such a big factor. Coaches who instill confidence often end up with really great results.

I also believe, from listening to past players of Bill Walsh, that a big part of his success was that the players had confidence in him as well. That he would do the right/best thing. They seemed to want to go to war for him...win it for him. That too is big IMO.

And this thread reminds me of a hitting coach my older son once used early in HS. He did not use a cookie-cutter approach to hitting. He looked at the way my son swung the bat and exploited his strengths to build a much better hitter with his lessons. The results he got were phenomenal...so much so that many of his teammates started seeing the same guy. And by the way, this guy was a tremendous confidence builder in the way he talked to him too. Everyone else I knew who used him got similar results but in different ways. Some hitters or pitchers you can look at and say, "Oh that kid goes to Joe Schmo, the local hitting instructor." Not with this guy.

Unfortunately, he moved to a different area of the state.

Bill Walsh was apparently a master at all of this from building confidence to enhancing individual skills to forming a team concept around his players' strengths.
The game of football makes it easier to exploit one's strengths and minimize weaknesses due to unique specialization and team play. In baseball you are more exposed as an individual to make plays offenseively and defensively. Some players are more adept at bunting, baserunning, fielding, etc. and can be utilized in special situations but it much more common it FB.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×