We went in 2005 and had a blast. 2B hit his first grand slam against a team from Colorado. We did think about going back the next year, but once he moved up to the big field, he wanted to stay there. He wasn't into all the pin-trading and all that stuff, but he loved playing a game or two every day and being there with all the other players. We went 6-3 and finished 25th or something like that, but one of our players won the Golden Arm competition. My only regret about not going back was not being able to see the Hank Aaron room, which wasn't completed when we were there.
The Cooperstown area is beautiful. We rented a cabin at a campground close to the facility and only paid $450 for the whole week. I agree that the food at the facility was bad. But we cooked on the grill at our cabin for most meals. There's a nice restaurant called Portabello's at a little town nearby, and several wineries to visit. Howe Caverns is fun, but it was cold! And of course we had lots of fun and spent way too much money in and around the HoF. I agree with Strike 3 that it is about the cash, and they must make a fortune. And a lot of those HRs turn in to fly ball outs in the fall. But still, for us, it was a really great trip.
The umpire that came with us had a great time, also.