First, thanks for all the great advice posted...I have read and re-read over the last few years as I have attempted to educate myself in the strange new world of baseball and now recruiting.
Have an older sibling in college so finances are an issue. Senior son, 4 yr varsity starter, moved from infield to catcher position junior year. Has more to learn but has excelled and gotten noticed by JUCOs, mid D1's and a few major D1's through summer ball and a few camps/Area Code try out.
Mid D1 has made an good offer and official visit is planned but his academic interest is not offered by this school. Academically-would have to compromise if he goes with this school. Very good possibility of playing time as they are graduating at his position. coach has been at almost all of his games. He is very wanted at this school which makes him and his parents feel good.
JUCO's are calling, going to meet with two of them next week. Nothing in writing but telling us they will pay for everything and he will get to play. Big plus.....He will get to play. new position and he needs to play to get better. These JUCO's have also been at a lot of games to watch him.
Now, major D1 has called and offered a roster spot. No $$ and others on team at his position that are on scholarship. Academic fit but not really a baseball fit as a freshman other than you are one the team in a uniform and get to practice, possibly earning $ in the future.
Please sound off.....Just a "cooler packer" and don't know the ends and outs of this recruiting roller coaster. Don't want to hurt any feelings especially a D1 college, but is there a good reason to just take a D1 roster spot over the playing time/$$ at a JUCO?
In my simple mind, I'm not finding the logic. Please help. I really appreciate all the posts on this message board and they have helped me greatly in understanding everything from recruiting to POP times. THANKS
Original Post