For Blprkfrnks & everyone else - let's lay out the application statistics. Here are some facts to color our conversation. I hope this can help you in your evaluation.
High School - public TX HS
GPA - (edited)
Class rank - (edited)
SAT - (edited)
Extracurricular - (edited)
Baseball - 4 years varsity. 4 years summer w/ top Dallas summer teams. You've heard of them.
Those are the lifeless statistics. The admissions office STARTS here, then looks for color. My recollection from the 2004 admissions tour meetings are as follows:
- All serious applicants are qualified academically
- 1025 applicants are accepted. 10-12K students apply.
- Dartmouth really values HS graduating class rank.
- Admissions prefers to see student applicants that have a passion for a single activity in their extracurricular portfolio. This is preferred over the applicant that has a smorgasbord of special interests listed on their application. Too many interests = not enough commitment to any one of them.
- Admissions looks to justify every acceptance letter by asking 'What unique qualities does this applicant have that will add value or diversity to the Dartmouth community?' (Yes, its a touchy-feely elite liberal question, but its their college). For my son his unique quality was that he was a shortstop entering school the year after the All-Ivy Dartmouth SS was graduating. Timing was everything.
quote:
When an athlete like your son is admitted to an ivy, using baseball skill as a hook, are they able to keep up academically with probably superior students and the rigors of competing in baseball? Or does the academic assistance provided to student athletes makeup for any differences?
Nobody flunks out of Dartmouth. You might not like your grades (I saw no evidence of grade inflation based on my son's experience), but if you work you'll graduate.
Succeeding academically is not impossible. DC does not experience nearly the travel schedule that most associate with D1 baseball. Baseball players major in Economics, English, Engineering, Psychology, Government, and they all minor in Baseball.
First off - All Ivy games are played Sat & Sun. Two DHs. A 7 inning game followed by a 9 inning game. For road trips in league play, the longest bus ride is Hanover to Princeton for Sat, Princeton to Cornell on Sat night for Sunday games, back to Hanover on Sunday night. Harvard is 2 hours away. Yale, 2.5. Brown might be 3 hours away. There is usually only 1 mid-week game per week. Never more than 4 hours away. You might miss class every other Wed, sometimes on FR for the long road trips south.
The whole school operates by laptop. Kids who need to can write papers & read text on the bus ride. Everyone has the same academic workload and mindset, so it not like you're the team geek because you study.
Another factor is the limited schedule imposed by Ivy League rules. I think that the Ivy League manages their athletic programs more appropriately than all other D1 conferences. Our kids go to college to gain an education, and the colleges emphasize education over athletics. As a result, Ivy League baseball is restricted to 12 fall practices instead of the NCAA mandated 20. Team schedules are limited to between 40-45 games, instead of NCAA maximum 56.
Finally - if your son is recruited by Dartmouth baseball and gains admission to the school, don't think twice. Accept the offer. I will wholeheartedly endorse any decision to attend Dartmouth, and it won't have anything to do with the baseball program. The Dartmouth diploma has presented more opportunities for my son than I could have imagined.