Skip to main content

Situation is runners on 1st and 2nd, 0 outs. Batter hits a soft low line drive to SS (never got more than 6 ft off ground). SS starts to catch ball, hits glove then intentionally drops it so to complete a double play. No IFF was called. Field umpire calls dead ball batter out quickly. SS had quickly (as umpire was calling the out), tagged runner on 2nd, tagged 2b trying to get double play. Runner on 2nd assuming he was out, left bag and began to run into to dugout, he was quickly tagged when once everyone realized umpirre had called dead ball. Umpire ruled runner safe on 2nd, 1 out as he called dead ball and everything stops at that moment. Should this not have been treated like an IFF fly, runners advance at own risk? and runner on second be called out for leaving bag?. I thought only dead ball on a live ball was when a batted ball hits a runner

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by NewUmpire:

Fed Rule: 5-1-1-j - the ball is dead immediately if the fielder intentionally drops a fair fly, line drive or bunt with at least first base occupied.    There is no IF Fly if the batted ball is a line drive or bunt.  Batter out, runners remain on 1st and 2nd.  Runner protected as soon as ump calls dead ball.

Gotta admit.  Not sure I ever heard this.  You say the fielder is not allowed to intentionally "drop" a fair fly, line drive or bunt.  Can they just let it fall?  Is it a judgement call by the ump whether he actually dropped it, or just misplayed it?  I am not 100%, but I could have sworn I've seen a bunt pop up intentionally allowed to hit the ground to try to get a DP.

 

Also, I thought the IFF rule was put in place so that a fielder couldn't intentionally allow a ball to drop and put the runners in a bad position.  If this rule you quote is in place, why would the IFF even be necessary? 

 

Just wondering.

Originally Posted by bballman:
Originally Posted by NewUmpire:

Fed Rule: 5-1-1-j - the ball is dead immediately if the fielder intentionally drops a fair fly, line drive or bunt with at least first base occupied.    There is no IF Fly if the batted ball is a line drive or bunt.  Batter out, runners remain on 1st and 2nd.  Runner protected as soon as ump calls dead ball.

Gotta admit.  Not sure I ever heard this.  You say the fielder is not allowed to intentionally "drop" a fair fly, line drive or bunt.  Can they just let it fall?  Is it a judgement call by the ump whether he actually dropped it, or just misplayed it?  I am not 100%, but I could have sworn I've seen a bunt pop up intentionally allowed to hit the ground to try to get a DP.

 

Also, I thought the IFF rule was put in place so that a fielder couldn't intentionally allow a ball to drop and put the runners in a bad position.  If this rule you quote is in place, why would the IFF even be necessary? 

 

Just wondering.

The fielder can let it fall (in the non-infield fly scenario) and the ball remains live.  If he "gloves" it or guides it to the ground, then the rule applies -- the batter is out and other runners return.

 

On most or at least a lot of infield flys at the MLB level the defense could still get a DP by letting the ball fall untouched - it would just bounce up to the fielder and hed turn two.  So you need both rules -- but you are right that they are related and there for about the same reasons.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×