This question may perhaps be better suited to the Draft forum, but I'm posting here because it is primarily a pitching query.
So...I took in a game at a college stadium this week. The scoreboard featured a radar gun reading for each pitch. Pitcher #1 was a righthander who threw a straight and flat fastball that hit 90-91 (although the gun may have been off). Four or five scouts behind the backstop had guns on him as well. Pitcher #2 was a lefthander of similar stature (both pitchers were around 6'1 or 6'2 and between 185 and 200 pounds). The lefthander topped out around 85-86 but had movement to his pitches and allowed only 1 unearned run through 7 or 8 complete innings. The righthander allowed 2 earned through 6 including a mammoth HR due, no doubt, to his straight fastball. The scouts did not pay attention to the lefty. Both pitchers were juniors (both Division One schools).
OK...so my question is, why would pitcher #1 be more desirable as a prospect -- the velocity and nothing more? Also, what is the lowest velocity a pitcher can theoretically sit at and get draft consideration? It seems to me that scouts almost singularly still love the guys who light up the gun.
Original Post