Skip to main content

My son has always played sports year round. While baseball is his first choice, he has also played football and basketball. While he still plays basketball with a pick up rec team every now and then, he plays baseball and football in HS (for a decent 2A level school – better in baseball than football). He is a 2013 grad and started varsity in both as a freshman.

The baseball team he is on for 2011 plays a pretty heavy fall season. The coach also takes a large # of players in the fall and will break the group into 2 teams for the summer season. While both will be good teams and get plenty of exposure, one is a much more prestigious team and gets all of the prime game slots and scout / recruiter attention.

The question is how hard does he push himself to do both sports? He is a big kid and plays TE/DE in football and feels pretty sore on Saturday's and Sundays when he plays baseball. After every baseball practice / game, he gets in the car and says 'Football is killing my baseball'. His overall feeling is that most of the other baseball players on the fall team fighting for a spot work all week on baseball and he isn't.

He did OK on his summer team last year (which was the younger age version of the prestigious team he wants to play on next year) and he hopefully will make the higher level team, but the competition is fierce and he will have to work at it to continue on. How do you tell a 15 year old to relax, enjoy his High School football experience, work out different muscles, get bigger, ... and that baseball will take care of itself?

The coaches have been real upfront, at least verbally, with the football players. They say that playing football will not hurt their chances in the least and missing baseball games / practices is not an issue. I have no reason not to believe them and they have been doing this for a long time.

My son enjoys Friday Night Football and everything that comes with it, but really has no aspirations of playing football in college (especially not at the level he hopes to play baseball at). We (baseball coaches included) judge the success of a football game, not in tackles or touchdown catches, but in not getting hurt. When would it make sense to stop playing football - or maybe taking his junior year off to go to some of the big fall baseball showcases / camps - and just focusing on baseball?

Oh, and I have not even mentioned schoolwork during this time. He struggled with grades his first year, but has since recommitted himself and with the help of his teachers and coaches (not to mention my big right foot), is doing much better this year.

Just looking for some insight as to what others in similar situations have done.
Last edited {1}
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Just my opinion, but let your son play football. Nothing is better than Friday Night Lights for a kid. My son didnt play football last year and focused on baseball. I think he got a little burned out and struggled some in the spring. This fall he decided to play football again because he missed hitting the snot out of people. Plus my son is on a fall travel baseball team that still allows him to get in some baseball from time to time. Let your son enjoy high school, talent will always shine in the end. I have spoken to a few college coaches and they always ask me if my son plays other sports. Good luck!
My son took the other path with this. We did the "Ben Franklin" thing where we discussed the pros and cons to each. The biggest negative to Football was the potential injury factor. A serious leg injury could set baseball back a year, a shoulder injury could end baseball.

My son knew that he wanted to play baseball in College. Football contact for him was fun but he didn't see himself playing beyond H.S.

Ultimately, he decided why "waste time" training for football and risk serious injury when he could get on with what he wanted to do.

Only your son can make that decision. There are many positives to playing Football on Friday's that others will chime in on. Scouts and Recruiters "love multi-sport" athletes!

Good luck.
It's pretty straightforward but tough...if a kid has designs on playing baseball in college he has to understand and accept the injury factor. Of course, injuries occur in baseball but not nearly as often or as seriously as in football. Football is a great game and many baseball coaches appreciate the "edge" that some football players bring to baseball. However, the pink elephant in the living room, the "injury factory" is there and won't go away.
My son enjoys Friday Night Football and everything that comes with it, but really has no aspirations of playing football in college (especially not at the level he hopes to play baseball at).
---------------------------------------------------

it's not always about the playing at the next level. you only get 4 yrs of hs, enjoy it. it's over way to quickly.

football teaches a mental toughness that carrys over very well to baseball. the bottom line is, it's his decision.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AlXDo5WhQXI

If you haven't seen it, watch.

High School Football is something special. It's not like any other sport or any other level. I'm sorry-- there's nothing that compares.


This is something that has to be decided by that specific individual. I am a big advocate of kids playing multiple sports. But I know one kid who shouldn't play football especially since he wants to play baseball at a high level. His sophomore football season was ended with a broken collarbone and he missed part of the basketball season as well. His junior football season was ended with a broken collarbone and he missed part of the basketball season as well. He is not playing as a senior.
A little different perspective for you. The what if happenend to my son on the football field in september of his freshman year. He tor his ACL. The total recovery time was over a year. He understood the risks accepted the risks and unfortunately had to deal with a horrible injury. He does not regret all the years he played football. He liked it and it was worth it to him. Do not live in fear and wrap your kid in bubble wrap until baseball season only to see him suffer a Chipper Jones or a Stepehn Strasburgh. Let his heart decide. both sports will be done for him very soon anyway unless he is the one in a million that plays in the MLB for years.
My older son played football, baseball, basketball and ran track as a freshman at a 5A school. He dropped track his sophomore year, basketball his junior year and football his senior year.

He tore his ACL in football just before Thanksgiving of his junior year and had surgery. He played his entire junior season in baseball with a knee brace and there was no phone calls in the summer for any, except one, D-1 school (the coach is a friend of mine). The coaches told me later they knew he was out there, but wouldn't take a chance on a player in a knee brace.

He made all-state and was drafted his senior year, relatively late then went to a major D-1 school. He was drafted again his sophomore year of college.

We not only knew of the risk of injury but ended up being affected by a major injury, but not in the long run. I'm not sure he would have been as good as he was without the other sports.

He would have played them all if if had it to do over again. I would suggest playing the other sports through the junior year and there is nothing wrong with playing out the senior year.

Hope this helps.
I think football can be a good way to toughen a kid up. We had a player this year who I suggested should play football to help him develop a little intestinal fortitude (we'll see if it works). But one thing I told him (he brought up the idea of playing to me, I simply thought it was a good idea) is that if you're going to play, you have to be 100% ready to go. If you tip toe around the football field, you will get yourself killed. Balls to the wall, head on a swivel, looking to do some damage when you get to the football...that is the only way to play.

Add Reply

Post
.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×