Here is my concern with weighted baseballs
1. Anything over 20% of the standard (a baseball in this case) will change mechanics when using that standard (the baseball).
This is in advanced athletes who are dialed into their mechanics. I dont know about you, but I know very few youth baseball players who can repeat their delivery exactly over and over and over. That is the whole point of practice. To get the pitcher doaled into their mechanics.
So, if you are using a weighted object, you will not onl be training outside proper mechanics you will actually be ingraining improper ones! As anyone knows, poor mechanics are very difficult to break out of.
In addition, if mechanics are slightly off injuries typically occur in other body parts such as the elbow and lower back, along with the shoulder.
This topic goes way past this post because I did not touch on topics such as arm speed, decelaration and release point. Just to name a few.
2. Long term repetitive stress injuries.
It is bad enough that throwing a baseball wrecks havoc on the shoulder. Adding weighted baseball will only further enhance this.
Sure you can do shoulder strengthening drills, but very few do these correctly.
Am I saying weighted baseballs will not increase performance? NO.
What I am saying is that I am very concerned with repetitive stress injuries.
It is very possible to do very well with weighted baseballs over a full off-season or even more. But at what cost? Is it worth a great deal of microtrauma that can lead to a tear? In my book the answer is no, especially when there are many other options that are proven to be effective and do not stress the body in a harmful matter.
These are just two of my concerns. The problem is the weighted baseballs are an easy sell. At first they "make sense." However, when looking into it deeper, the risks far outweigh the benefits IMO.