Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Absolutely scold. There is never a time that a player should speak out to an umpire, or anyone on the field for that matter. I believe the coach just went out to the umpire afterward so that his player did not look that bad, in my mind, it is highly doubtful he said anything of great significance. The player, however, will be a topic of humor for quite a while, as it had me laughing for quite a bit at the simple fact that what he did was totally outrageous and unbelievable it was funny.
What he should have done is just run down to 1B (as you would on a pitch that just nips the jersey).

I think his over-acting is what caused the problem.

To justify a reaction like that, you'd have to have been hit on the bone. If that happens, then the path of the ball changes and you can hear the ball hit the bone.

What he should have tried to sell is a ball that just brushed his forearm.
quote:
Originally posted by CollegeParent:
My son showed me this video. Reminds me of s****r.


I love s****r at the youth level, but it's stuff like this that makes me lose respect for it at the pro level.

Too often guys go off the field seemingly writhing in pain on in a stretcher and then pop right off of the stretcher as soon as play resumes.

It's kind of pathetic.
quote:
Why did the coach go have "words" with the ump?


I can only assume that from the dugout he could not have seen how blatantly far the player was missed. I believe they were in the dugout behind the player and that he went out to support his player.........and in that I am sure he is more angry about...now that the countless replays have proven not only was his player faking, but that his reaction was unwarrented....
Last edited by piaa_ump
shortstopmom- No matter how blatantly inappropriate a player's actions are, I think its a coach's prerogative to try to protect his team as much as he can. I'm sure he said nothing meaningful to the umpire, and the umpire understood he was just trying to protect his player. What I'd like to know is what the coach(es) said to the player post-game in the locker room.
What would a typical repercussion be for a college player who acted this way? ( other than getting thrown from the game ) Does anyone know how the coach handled it? Does anyone have an opinion as to what they think should happen,..if anything? I'm curious.

( Were still at the HS level, so not sure how things work at the college level, these days. )
Last edited by shortstopmom
As the mother of a son who was actually hit by a pitch that resulted in major bodily harm, I am disgusted by this player.

I am offended that even pretending that he was hit is accepted.

It's bad enough when a player does get hit by a pitch--accidentally. It happens. But to pretend to be hit--with such theatrics....

No, his behavior shouldn't be condoned. But the behavior that I am concerned about is not that he pointed his bat at the umpire.

He needs to think of that oh-so-very-catchy phrase--"There, but for the grace of God go I."

Would he think that it was a joke then?
Last edited by play baseball
time for the players prospective!!!!!

looks to me like this was a case of the catcher (walker) trying to stir something up with the umpire. although there are a lot of good umpires out there, there are some bad ones and some that are just jerks. it was the third inning, something happened before this between the ump and the catcher and the coach prolly knew about it from his reaction. and i love a coach going to bat for his player. all in all i know both coach and player regret this happening.
Rock- I'm a player also. I doubt the coach regrets this. He might regret having a player on his team act the way he did, but he can use it as an example for the future. The player can be a "guinea pig" of sorts here. And I don't know if the player had something against the umpire prior to his at-bat, only he probably knows that. Either way, why act out like that?

quote:
If ya need a freebie that bad at least have the courage to lean into it...


clapping Agree 100%
Rock, you may be correct in thinking that the player and umpire had issues prior to this, although I can't quite understand how acting the fool would set those issues to right. But this guy has a few problems.

Catchers and umpires have a unique relationship in the game, and smart catchers know how to keep an umpire of any ilk as sweet as possible. Good catchers would have the cajones to lean into the pitch --- it was inside, below the neck, above the knee; pretty much textbook.

One might also assume a player would be aware that the ball generally changes direction when it hits you hard enough to cause that kind of reaction.

Methinks he's not studying physics, psychology or theater arts.
Last edited by Orlando

Add Reply

Post
.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×