Skip to main content

Someone recently commented to me on a message board not to mess with a guy because there is no way I know as much baseball as he does. I've been around baseball for a long time. My father, grandfathers, and most relatives are good baseball men. Baseball has been my life for as long as I can remember. I had played in college for a short time before an arm injury ended that and now coach. I guess I take offense to the comment itself and just wondered how much do people actually know about baseball as they claim they do? I don't want this to be a big p-ss--g contest. I know some of you played D1 ball or pro ball etc. or coached at that level, but some of the guys I played with were some of the dumbest baseball men I have encountered. Anyway. How do you quantify baseball knowledge? Any comments?
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Thanks coach. Good advice. I have never claimed ever to know everything about baseball and try to learn something new everyday. Some of the smartest baseball people I have been around never played beyond high school, they did'nt have the physical talent but they had a passion and love for the game. They always tried to learn more about it.
After talking to some guys who played the game for a long time, I often wondered if they were paying attention to the game all the while. Some learn some don't bother. A lot of coaches are guys who studied the game while they played, regardless of how good they were.

Take it from me, I know more about baseball then most of you guys ever will.
Bullet,

I am checking the roster archives to see if I ever played with you before I answer .lol. I'm probably one of the dummies!
I think experience in the game is the biggest teacher , regardless whether you played or coached. I learned a ton from many good baseball men as a player but it wasnt because I was a player, IT WAS BECAUSE I LISTENED AND WANTED TO LEARN FROM AS MANY A I POSSIBLY COULD.
Bullet, I know your club and the people involved with your program, there is no question you are learning from them and they are learning from you. Its how it works.
I guess I have been around awhile to at least say that I have some experience with baseabll. My father played minor league ball in the late thirties, early forties. He never met his potential and I most certainly didn't meet mine. Having said that, my son has explained some things to me in recent years that I was unknowledgable about. Yes, you can teach an old dog new tricks.

As you continue to watch baseball games, you can most definitely pick-up new things. Look at what Pierzynski did by running to first base on what appeared to be 'strike three'. His foresight forced the umpires to make a most difficult judgement call. What I learned was that,no player should take anything for granted. Runout the play!! Don't be like many lazy players. BUT, I'm sure that catchers will take that incident and remember to throw down to first base on every 'swinging (dropped) third strike, whether they thought he was out or not.

Anyway, I have a friend who umpired college baseball in Colorado, and we spent one evening talking about different situations, plays, calls. WOW, how enlightning!!!!! We think we know alot! They deserve much more respect for their knowledge than we give them credit for. They do make mistakes, and they always try to be consistent and make-up for those mistakes. These people are where we can gain more knowledge about the game. I'm still learning.
Last edited by BoomerIL
I try to think that it is not how much you know but whether you can pass it on to others. I have been blessed to have been around some great baseball people who communicate their passion and love for the game. I am also not too proud to have " borrowed " alot from other people who's ego was to teach and respect the game and your opponent . It was and always will be an honor to step foot on the diamond and compete in the 6,7. or 9 inning war that is baseball and then to shake the hand of the team who you just try to beat and then shake the hands of your teammates and coaches knowing that everyone involved left it all on the field.
Many great knowledgeable baseball minds...The truly knowledgeable know that the key to this game of failure is being able to respond and react to imperfection. The coach that can instill in a player the virtues that become the tools for building confidence, overcoming fear and as we all know fear hovers over perfectionism. The real key is being able to convey the message, that's what separates the truly great coaches from the pack..If you can develop that bond...boy that's magic..when a kid comes back after getting drafted and says Coach we did this or I wouldn't be here without you! Magic! Being able to confront fear and allowing yourself to fail and not dwelling on it, is the core foundation to success in baseball and life! So if that D1 scholarship doesn't come, the knowledgeable coach will have given the lad a far greater gift. The ability to move forward and the realization that mistakes aren't failures at all, rather the stepping stones to success. The truly knowledgeable coach knows how to help a player through difficult times not by slick production or lecture, rather being able to reinvigorate and re-energize the confidence and helping the kid to believe in himself again. It's a strange paradox that all of the great baseball minds have over the years stated that "Baseball is 90% mental, why then do coaches spend so little time on this facet of the game (New thread topic) Walk into any baseball school and you will hear the crack of the bats...not much talking...Lot's to still learn.


Deleted per a number of request.
Last edited by CoachB25
Socrates said it and I agree. I find myself, at times, wanting to expound on my great knowledge (LOL) and prove that I'm the next best thing to sliced bread. I can quote my GPA from college including all of the awards gather there, then factor in all of my accolades from the teacher profession. Boy, I am smart and great. Then I remember to remind myself of that quote about not knowing anything. Humility is a virtue. That is found somewhere in some black book. Knowledge comes from knowing what you know and then realizing that what you know might not be the truth as perceived by others. It’s kind of like is my red your red. You know, we can agree that that color is recognized by both of us as red but are you seeing my blue but have always been told it is red. Ok, so now I’ve convinced you that I’m not smart at all.

I love to sit and listen to baseball people who have all of the answers and portray themselves as the expert. Most of them have a rude awakening coming when they get bypassed by people such as we have here on this site who want to continuing learning about this great game. We would all do well when thinking about how smart we are or about winning to remember a quote by John Madden:

"When victory is achieved, that feeling can be overwhelming. Keep your common sense about you and be gracious. Silence is often the best practice after a win. If you must talk, praise your opponent and praise your teammates. Never praise yourself.

Why do so many athletes feel the need to tell everyone what happened - how they won, how well they performed? If you win, if you are good, people will see it. They will know without you telling them. Your job is to perform, not report.

Self-praise is for losers. Be a winner. Stand for something. Always have class and be humble.

The most important thing to do after winning is to get right back to work. Winning can actually have a negative influence if you become satisfied with yourself. Even in victory, be critical and look for mistakes you might have made. Never be completely satisfied; always search for ways to improve.

My biggest guard is against becoming too satisfied when we win. There are many times when you've got to put the joy of winning behind you and look ahead to what really is uncertainty."

John Madden
Last edited by CoachB25
TBS

I don't think you under stand the concept. It is not an easy way out. Admitting that one does not know makes them wanting to know more. People who say they know everything are wrong. Only God can say that. Knowledge is a wonderful thing but abusing it can cause more harm then good. When it comes to baseball coaches can make decisions that will make them heroes and people will say he must really know baseball and that same decision can lose the game for them the next day. There are millions of people with a million different ideas and all of them are the best. I can tell you that I love to watch the game, I love to watch my son play, and I can question coach’s decisions all I want but that doesn't mean I know more. I like the quote from Coach Russ Gangler, "It worked, so I made the right call".

The original post asked - How do you quantify baseball knowledge?

My opinion is there is no real answer because it is a never ending process.

For people to say I know more than you are immature and ignorant but to be able to admit that you need to learn more is truly knowledgeable.
Last edited by Bill McClain
Great posts Bill and coachb,
My dad "who wasnt the smartest guy in the world when I was 16" once said to me after a good game I had that "no matter how good you are or how smart you think you are there is always someone out there who is smarter and better than you". He is alot smarter now that I am in my 30's. I didnt understand the meaning then and thought he was putting me down. Now I use that phrase all the time to players I coach.
Last edited by SIBullets
How much do I know about baseball?

If you were to drop me into England or India, I would say that I was in the top 1% of the most baseball savvy people in that country (of course, everyone would want to talk about cricket anyway). Here in the US, there are thousands of people who have more baseball knowledge than I do. Even while I work hard to learn as much as I can continuously, so do they. I'll never catch them. Instead, I'll use them to learn. That should keep me just far enough ahead of the younger crowd to be able to help them as they try to learn all they can.

On this board there are many great baseball people. I am not one of them (maybe someday). Over a little time, I think it becomes easy to identify the truly smart ones...their posts have more ?'s than !'s.

Mike F
MikeF, you made me laugh with your India anaolgy. It felt like I got dropped into Russia one time. Acutally the Soviet Union and Lithuana but... Anyway, I was there to help coach them and they were putting together their Olympic Team structure. Talk about being smart, I told them to get their arms loose and then we'd go over some stuff. Not bright on my part. They had never played catch and so, they were throwing in every concievable direction. Mountains of men they called ball players were getting drilled in every direction. That's when I knew that "Playing catch" was Z and I had skipped A-Y!!! I'm a little smarter now. LOL!
Coach B

quote:
Originally posted by CoachB25:
That's when I knew that "Playing catch" was Z and I had skipped A-Y!!! I'm a little smarter now. LOL!


I'll bet that you had a blast6 when it was all said and done. And you just gave me an analogy that I will use going forward...playing catch is Z, and I'm all about A-Y.

Thanks,

Mike F
Last edited by Mike F

Add Reply

Post
.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×