Skip to main content

Ok so we are taking semester finals and I'm bored which is never good so I start thinking.  It's amazing the things I talk myself into and out of when I have this much time on my hands.

 

Anyway - runner going to first on a bunt or dropped third strike.  Catcher throws the ball to first but runner is in fair territory and hits him.  This guy is out.  

So my situation let's say there is a runner on third and hard shot right down the line and runner is going on contact.  But as he's going home he veers inside the line and is now in fair territory.  Third baseman comes up throwing to the plate but the throw hits the runner while in fair territory.  Is he still out like the runner going to first?

I'm thinking he's not because it's a different situation since there isn't a running lane. 

The 3 foot to each side of the baseline wouldn't factor in here since he isn't trying to avoid a tag.

It wouldn't be any different than a throw from the OF hitting a runner trying to go to third.

Would it matter if the runner threw his arms up when he saw the catcher raise his hands to catch the ball and gets hit?

See I had too much time on my hands.

Nothing can stop the man with the right mental attitude from achieving his goal; nothing on earth can help the man with the wrong mental attitude. Thomas Jefferson

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

You're pretty much correct. RLI can only be committed by a BR running TO first on a throw TO first--anywhere else, a throw anywhere else, there is no required lane for a runner.

As for throwing the hands up, we now are in the realm of potential intentional interference. A live runner is not guilty of interference if he unintentionally interferes with a thrown ball (except for RLI,) but intentionally interfering with one is illegal.

Last edited by Matt13

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×