Skip to main content

From a HS "player" standpoint, is LaCrosse the next threat to baseball? I know s****r takes a few good athletes from baseball each year, but I think it has leveled off.

A recent article in my local paper interviewed the Lacrosse coach at a prep school. He said he takes all the undersized football players with exceptional talent and makes them elite lacrosse athletes. He then commented that there are numerous unfilled scholarships in lacrosse and has success with many of his players signing every year, whereas they would be too small to sign in a college football program. He said the 5-10, 165 pound player that is a little small for football makes a great lacrosse player.

HS lacrosse is played during baseball season. I know of one example where a very talented baseball player left and is now playing lacrosse. I wonder if more will do the same? I imagine the hand/eye coordination from baseball would transfer directly to lacrosse. I doubt it will ever be a big spectator sport in the US, but it is a contact sport that takes a well rounded athlete. Hands, eyes, running, quickness, lots of scoring, etc.

My son is young and has never played lacrosse, but is going to give it a try this summer in a camp.

Just wondering what everyone thinks about it and if there are other baseball players leaving for that sport. BTW, only reason I say "leaving baseball" is because the season conflict. Both lacrosse and baseball are Spring sports. Would be nearly impossible to play both in a HS program.
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

It's all up to the athlete. One sport doesn't really rob another sport of its players. The players make a choice what sport they'd rather play. If a baseball player decides to move to lax, then that opens a spot for a new player on the baseball team so nobody loses out on any players. More options to pick a sport is a good thing
Last edited by zombywoof
quote:
Originally posted by infidel_08:
How many LAX scholarships can a school have?


Well, I learned a new abbreviation today... "LAX"

At any rate, here's some info I copied from an NCAA website for LAX:

"Unlike football lacrosse is classed as an equivalency sport. This simply means that coaches can share their financial aid allocation between a larger number of players. If you are good enough of course then a full ride scholarship is always on the cards.

The NCAA allows each Division I lacrosse program 12.69 scholarships for men and 12 for women. In Division II there are 10.8 scholarships for men and 9.9 for women."

I think the word "threat" I used in the subject is too strong. I know the sports can co-exist. But, the seasons are at the same time. So, athletes can't play both. They have to make a choice and LAX is gaining popularity and there is much opportunity for scholarship. I dislike seeing stud baseball players quit and choose another sport. I've seen this in s****r. One example I've seen was an awesome shortstop/hitter, leave baseball and move to travel s****r. He eventually blew-out his knee in s****r (very common in that sport) and now is struggling between physical rehab and s****r. Sad case and isolated, I agree. But still, an example of a player that I wished had stayed in baseball.

I hope my son continues his love of baseball, but LAX has piqued his interest and he's giving it a try in a week long camp this summer.
I don't believe the threat comes at the middle or high school level. By then kids have developed a passion for baseball or they haven't. They're displaying baseball skills or they're not. Those who have it will stay with baseball as long as they can.

I believe the threat of losing kids to lacrosse is at the preteen levels. It happens when the kid has a poor youth baseball coach and stands in the field picking his nose while one player hits during BP. Then his friend tells him how much fun he has running around the entire lacrosse practice.

Like many posters here, my son is one of the best athletes in his class. When he was thirteen I was approached by the director of the club lacrosse program. He saw speed and aggressiveness. He pointed out the increased odds of college scholarship if he switched to lacrosse. I told the guy my son isn't playing sports for a ride. He plays for the enjoyment and stuck with baseball.

Lacrosse is not for pussies. At the high school level the players are beating each other with sticks up and down the field. I love watching the game. It's fast and physical.
Last edited by RJM
quote:
Lacrosse might be a threat in the northeast, but not anywhere else that I know. It is getting more popular, but it isn't a school sport in AZ.
It's a big time sport in Virginia, Maryland, Pennsylvania and New York.

quote:
I can see why Jim Brown almost changed the sport.
He did change the sport. There's the Jim Brown rule. Since Brown, players have not been allowed to cup the ball to their chest and run over players advancing down the field.
Last edited by RJM
Whenever I'm calling a game and there is a LAX game going on too, I'll ask the catcher: "What's that silly game they're playing over there with nets on sticks? Are they trying to catch bugs, birds & squirrels?" Gets a laugh (most) every time.

I grew up and still live on Long Island. By far, the most scholarships (especially Ivy league) are for that "silly" sport.
quote:
Originally posted by Doughnutman:
From what I have seen of lacrosse, I wouldn't be recruiting from the baseball team, I would recruit from the football team.
Our high school has a good lacrosse program. Most of the team isn't recruited from another sport. They're playing summer club lacrosse and focused on the sport. There are a few football players and some of the more physical s****r players.
quote:
Originally posted by Doughnutman:
4 out of 50 states? Not real popular south of the border or in Asia? I think baseball will be fine. Sounds like a regional problem to me.


There are D1 lacrosse programs in 18 states & DC. States are:
CT, NY, VA, PA, VT, MD, CO, NJ, RI, SC, OH, IN, NC, MA, DC, MI, DE, NH, & KY.

There are D1 lacrosse programs at big-time schools such as:
Syracuse
Duke
Georgetown
Maryland
UNC
Virginia
and how about this one,
Notre Dame

Not saying its a serious threat too baseball.........yet. Just pointing out the facts.
Was regional, but growing and spreading at a pretty good rate.
quote:
Originally posted by Doughnutman:
From what I have seen of lacrosse, I wouldn't be recruiting from the baseball team, I would recruit from the football team.

I was talking with a D1 college LAX player from Maryland who now coaches high school in FL. He told me the prototypical lacrosse player is 6-2 about 190 pounds. The average D1 baseball player is about 6-0 200#. Culturally and physically there is more overlap with baseball than football, to me.
Last edited by Dad04
quote:
Originally posted by Dad04:
quote:
Originally posted by Doughnutman:
From what I have seen of lacrosse, I wouldn't be recruiting from the baseball team, I would recruit from the football team.

I was talking with a D1 college LAX player from Maryland who now coaches high school in FL. He told me the prototypical lacrosse player is 6-2 about 190 pounds. The average D1 baseball player is about 6-0 200#. Culturally and physically there is more overlap with baseball than football, to me.
The football players you see in high school lacrosse are usually backs and linebackers. Linebackers often make good defensive players with their physical play.

Add Reply

Post
.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×