quote:
Originally posted by DECK:
This is a fun one, and almost exactly on-point to something we discussed at great lengths in a recent seminar. Here's my interpretation: It's not a 'balk' just because the pitcher drops it (even tho both base coaches will be screaming 'balk' right from the beginning...it's a LIVE ball, and runners are free to advance. It becomes a 'balk' when (after being dropped) it's touched by the pitcher or another defensive player...or becomes a 'ball' when it rolls across one of the baselines. Of course, by the time it rolls that far the runner is probably to 3rd.
With runners on, it becomes a balk when it stops short of crossing the baseline. Your touch theory is interesting but not does not align with the rule.