Ok so let's look at the other side. Coaches have their favorite players, players have their favorite coaches.
What makes a coach a players favorite?
1. knows how to really coach and manage a team
2. impartial ( ex. does a player play because he is good or just his son)
3. no BS, plays the best 9, not kiss up favorites
4. willing to work on every aspect with every player from their weaknesses to their strengths to make them better, not just work with their favorites
5. is willing to take responsibility for their own mistakes and not pass blame to players
6. will stand up for their players and team
7. knows how to motivate POSITIVELY
8. will bench all players when they need to be benched (unproductive or doesn't follow team rules), this includes the prospects
9. will give all players an opportunity to prove themselves for a position
10. fair
Original Post