I do think the byes hurt although some of the teams with byes weren’t playing well going into the post season. Husband and I were just talking about what teams can do to stay sharp. We both thought scrimmages with AA/AAA guys would be an interesting option. You’d probably have to pull from Arizona Fall League rosters.
I've been saying the layoff hurt those teams. You spend 6 months playing 5 to 6 days a week during that span and routine is imperative to baseball to stay sharp. Half the bye teams lost and I think both bye teams lost last year (less time than this year). I keep seeing people say the Braves had 4 days off last year and they did fine. They also played the Brewers who were off the same amount of time too so that's a wash.
End of the day it's the system in place and if you want to win then go out and get it done. But I'm curious to see if in like 5 years around 60% of the bye teams lose their series if this will get serious consideration unlike how it is now.
I would think using MiLB pitchers would be the best method to let hitters face but great point about pulling them from AFL to do so. Plus they just had their seasons end and do you want to keep them going further after their own downtime before AFL started?