Position Change

Just a thought here rshif13, but here is an idea. Volunteer to catch a few bullpens, or ask to get behind the plate during an inter squad to give your catchers a breather. Since you are only a sophomore you have some time. A little patience and maybe some discussions with your coaches and you might get that shot.

If you look at the other catchers in the program (juniors, sophomores and freshmen at all levels) and think you will be able to help the team better than they can, there is certainly nothing wrong with asking the coach for a look.  Something like... "Coach, I'm happy playing MIF or any position you need me.  But I just want to make sure you are aware I've been catching quite a bit in Legion ball and would love a chance to get some reps at practice there so you can determine if that might be a spot I can help."

You also mentioned you pitch some.  Keep in mind that Pitcher/Catcher can be the most difficult combination for a player to juggle and some programs/coaches won't even consider having a player do both.  So, if you think you might be a key contributor on the mound, this may not be the best direction to take.

Best wishes.

 If your pretty good behind the plate, you may find your new home once the Coach see's your skills. But I love your Team first approach.

I primarily see my self as a catcher, 

It really does not matter what you see it is what the coaches see. Might sound a little cold but that is the way it is

While that is true, it doesn't hurt to broach the subject with the coach as he may be unaware of the OP's skills as a catcher.  The coach may be pleasantly surprised.

The bottom line is the coach will put the kid in the best position to help the team. 

I don't think any coach would take offense if you asked to be looked at as a catcher.

Sure, the coach would make you earn playing time.  But if you can hit, then even if you are not the # 1 catcher, I should think that presenting yourself as an option there would not lead you to end up on the bench if you would otherwise be the best option at one of the MIF positions.

Worst case scenario, coach says, "That's interesting, but we are really well stocked at catcher.  So just focus on MIF."  Best case, coach lets you try both and uses you as needed. 

BTW, with three seasons to go -- this one and two more -- the answer may vary year to year, depending on who else is on the team each year.  It's not at all unusual to see a guy in your shoes playing out of position when a senior is ahead of him, but when your bat has earned you a spot in the lineup.  But when that senior graduates, if you are then the best option, you can claim your preferred position.

For collegiate recruiting, if you get into that, having multiple positions is a big plus, especially if one of them is at catcher.  So, I don't see why you wouldn't pursue this.  Just stay respecful of the coach's authority at all times.  Offer it as you volunteering or expressing an interest, not in any words that someone might misconstrue as you making a demand of any sort.