Skip to main content

Fortunately we have been able to send our son to a few dozen baseball camps over the years and feel they are a very important part of the recruiting proces.  Some were great and some not so great with coaches nowhere to be found, hearing the same recruiting talk Sat and Sun, no evaluation even after emailing coach for :60 time etc  Talking with the coaches ahead of time helps but not always. Could it be beneficial to have a forum to allow posters on this board to rate the camps?  Maybe a generic form that had same questions and then a comment area.  Some areas of interest might be 1. Number of participants (rough guess) 2. Did you get receive a written evaluation 3. Did Head Coach watch and interact one on one with players. 4. Was time well spent...camp format, etc.  These are just a few rough ideas.  Most kids can only afford a few camps each year and.having this information could be helpful.  Not trying to bash camps in any way - just this past weekend son got his second D1 offer at a camp that we don' t think had seen him play prior to that.  These camps are generally pretty expensive it would be great to have a way to review. Like a "Tripadvisor" for camps.

Last edited by Carolina Girl
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Lefthookdad's response reminds me of a story:

 

Sometime in the Fall of my son's junior year, he attended a "prospect" camp at an ACC school (In this instance, not the one he ultimately attended.). During one of the camp's breaks, the school's lead recruiter came over to me to say "hello." 

 

When asked how he rated the talent level of the 40-or-so players present, he replied that there were 3 or 4 who were capable of contributing regularly to an ACC roster.

 

In support of lefthookdad's response, the point I'd take from this camp experience would be that if you were a parent of one of the "3 or 4," you probably came away from it felling pretty good about it. At the other end of the spectrum, some parents of the remaining 36 or 37 probably left dissatisfied that their sons didn't get enough attention and/or praise. Meanwhile, those whose sons attended with other goals in mind (skills improvement, camp experience, etc.) probably went away with a varying array of assessments.

 

Seems to me that one's objectives for the camp experience and self-assessment of skills level would threaten to skew the results pretty significantly.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×