So now we know that burners can't hit. So let's resort to stealing first base.
Is a player any less valuable if he can successfully bunt for a base hit, routinely beat out infield grounders, put added pressure on the defense causing them to make errors, get lucky enough to drop in a few base hits, and be a catalyst in the game by using his speed?
Is he less desirable than the player who hits that occasional homerun or long out to the ohhs and ahhs of the spectators? Is he?
When the season is over, what do you remember? You remember those homeruns. You don't remember the .250 BA or the Ks from the slugger, nor do you remember that the burner batted over .400 again, got things started game after game and scored after an infield single, a steal of 2nd and 3rd and a sacrifice fly.
Which player is the more talented? Which player is really more deserving of those ohhs and ahhs? Who do you take on your team-Ichiro or Dave Kingman?
Original Post