Skip to main content

Hello to all, new to these forums (been lurking for a few months) and am seeking input from any parents who have had kids who were at any point switch hitters, and of course any other coaches/scouts/baseball minds out there. I've read several of the other threads here re: switch hitting and also have been around a few switch hitters in the high school and college ranks, so I am aware of (most) of the pros and cons of switch hitting. Being a father; however, is obviously new, and I am for whatever reason intimidated by teaching even the basics of the game. I'm sure some understand, but I am very good with the advanced stuff, but starting from scratch, it is like "where do I start?'

 

My boy is just a shade over 3 years old and has started his love affair with baseball. We have been mostly playing catch (rocket left-handed arm for his age BTW) and only brought out the tee a couple times. Last night I brought him outside with the tee and my jaw dropped. I could not believe how advanced his swing path was and I don't know how it got that way. I'm talking compact, hands inside the ball, stays in the hitting zone, contact out in front, and then a long follow through that he must have picked up watching games on TV. And 9 times out of 10 they were solid line drives with power. Hand placement and bat tilt before the swing need some work (lol) but still.

 

He is ambidextrous. I batted and threw right so I am guessing he can thank mom for that. His left arm has a little more life than the right, but he prefers left and it would be silly not to ride the left handed arm all things being equal. From the plate, he grabs the bat and wants to go to the left handed side. Out of curiosity, I had him take some cuts from the right side. Not nearly impressive, with the long, loopy swing you would expect from someone his age. But he still had the coordination from that side and made solid contact frequently and by my estimation, still rather advanced for his age.

 

So I am seeking whatever input you guys will throw at me. I am trying to be cognizant of not being a father who puts too much pressure on his boys (I also have a newborn). My father was that way and there were times he pushed me too hard.  I snapped and he backed off, but after that it was a chore to get him to take me to the park for BP or to catch a bullpen. Should I just ride that left handed bat of his and focus on repetition, fine tuning things as he ages so he can be a lefty who has the proper mechanics and approach to have at minimum, some success against LHP? Should I keep giving him cuts from both sides of the plate, or could that have a negative effect at this age, losing reps from the left side aside? Should I just let him pick up the bat and do whatever he wants to do and try the switch hitting when he is a little older? What age if so?

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by lionbaseball:
At 3 y.o. all my son's could hold a snocone with either hand.  I don't think any of mine picked up a ball or bat until 6.

My son could switch hit from 3 - 6 years old.  I mean he was equal from both sides of the plate.  We used to go outside, and he would love to take cuts every day.  However, one day, he decided that he only wanted to bat from the right side.  I would say, no you need to keep taking cuts from the left. For whatever reason, he didn't want to do it anymore.  I decided that I didn't want to take the fun out of it for him, so he now throws left, and bats right.

When mine was about 2 1/2 for Christmas we got his older brother (then 4) the first padded wiffle ball bat and puff ball set.  The older boy could have cared less but the not quite 3 year old picked up the bat and swung it with authority from the left side.

 

I would toss him the ball from 5-8 feet away and he tracked that thing and took some great hacks and made solid contact a good percentage of the time.  I really never changed that swing and no coach he had ever did either.  He was just born with it and never could get enough of it for the next 15 years.

RGDeuce, if this is real (and you will meet some skepticism because your kid is ONLY 3), then I would say you are way overthinking this. At 3, you can't even be sure that your kid is truly left handed, right handed or ambidextrous. My lefty started playing t-ball at 4. Threw left but refused to bat left because every other kid batted right. Oh well. He did that for a couple years and then started batting left. We tried the switch hitting thing for a while around 7 or 8, but he just felt more comfortable hitting left.

 

At this age, just have fun. Don't make anything too serious. A lot of kids have surprisingly strong arms at that age. Soak it all in and enjoy your young son. You have a lot of time before you need to worry about any of this stuff.

Originally Posted by RGDeuce:

       
Originally Posted by 2020dad:
Why do I suspect a hoax here?  If so, kudos that was funny.  If this is legit...  I am not sure what to say.

Why would you suspect this is a hoax? Just looking for some advice/help. Or maybe I'm just overthinking the entire thing, in which case, I can take that feedback as well.


       

At 3 just make sure he is having fun because at some point baseball will become work. 
Just the other day my 16 y.o. told me he wants to start batting left handed. Lol
Originally Posted by lionbaseball:
Originally Posted by RGDeuce:

       
Originally Posted by 2020dad:
Why do I suspect a hoax here?  If so, kudos that was funny.  If this is legit...  I am not sure what to say.

Why would you suspect this is a hoax? Just looking for some advice/help. Or maybe I'm just overthinking the entire thing, in which case, I can take that feedback as well.


       

At 3 just make sure he is having fun because at some point baseball will become work. 
Just the other day my 16 y.o. told me he wants to start batting left handed. Lol

My 15 y.o. just told me he wanted to start switch pitching since that is all the rage now. lol

Damn! You have a newborn and you haven't pushed him up to the plate? He's falling behind already.

 

When my son was 18 months old I got him a Little Tykes bat and tee. We got him a Little Tykes shopping cart I filled with whiffle balls and dead tennis balls. I showed him where to stand and a basic swing. It was his favorite toy. Almost every day I came home from work there were balls all over the yard. The only instruction I gave him before age eleven was when you're done, pick up after yourself. On nights and weekends I would sometimes play with him. I only teed up the balls and helped him retrieve them.

 

At at six he preferred attending his sister's 12u travel softball practices, shagging balls and hitting off the machine after practice. He said it was better than playing tee ball like a baby. I didn't provide any instruction on his swing until he was eleven. Anything preceding was natural.

 

On the flip side my daughter asked for some instruction the night before her first 7/8 machine pitch softball practice. Until high school she never practiced away from the team. They both ended up in the same place, college ball.

 

 

Originally Posted by kandkfunk:
Originally Posted by lionbaseball:
Originally Posted by RGDeuce:

       
Originally Posted by 2020dad:
Why do I suspect a hoax here?  If so, kudos that was funny.  If this is legit...  I am not sure what to say.

Why would you suspect this is a hoax? Just looking for some advice/help. Or maybe I'm just overthinking the entire thing, in which case, I can take that feedback as well.


       

At 3 just make sure he is having fun because at some point baseball will become work. 
Just the other day my 16 y.o. told me he wants to start batting left handed. Lol

My 15 y.o. just told me he wanted to start switch pitching since that is all the rage now. lol

I taught my son how to throw and catch when he was three. While I had him hitting left we couldn't determine which hand he was. He displayed signs of being ambidextrous. By five it was obvious he was left handed. But he kept throwing right handed (it ticked me off I couldn't play short after LL).

 

When he was twelve he heard about Venditte at Creighton. He started working on throwing left handed. After a couple of months he decided it was too much work given his preference was to play short over pitching. He did pitch through high school. With velocity and a change he didn't need to throw lefty.

LOL. I can promise this is not a hoax. Anyone who has been around the game has all met the parent who had a kid who "throws 90" when he is really 75, and "signed a NLI with ____" before he is allowed to even sign, and I will never been one of those dads. I can see the skepticism, like I said, my jaw dropped with what I saw. It was probably just the perfect storm of luck and everything else, and by no means when I talk about his swing am I implying its a work of art like Tony Gwynn. It was just not something I have ever seen at anything close to that age and I was trying to give some context.

 

Again, wanted to thank everyone for the input and advice up to this point, as well as the ribbing. I just need to go back to not overthinking and letting him progress and pick things up naturally, and I got ahead of myself when I saw what I did last night.  

 

In my short time of lurking I can tell this is a great place, and I promise I will keep any insane stories to myself until he is old enough to have them show up on the net or in the local paper

On a serious note, it is probably a good idea to figure out as natuarlly as possible which hand a kid favors.  Instead of going out and buying his a glove, go out in the backyard and toss tennis balls and see how he fields them.  Have him throw without a glove - put the tennis ball on the ground, have him pick it up and throw it.  As for batting, place the bat on the ground, have him pick it up and hit off a tee.  I remember helping out with a new kid in 7/8 yo league - figured out the kid was left handed but had been given a glove for his left hand.  Never did get him switched over fully.  Sort of like early writing instruction - be careful and do not assume the kid writes right handed.

Originally Posted by 2017LHPscrewball:

On a serious note, it is probably a good idea to figure out as natuarlly as possible which hand a kid favors.  Instead of going out and buying his a glove, go out in the backyard and toss tennis balls and see how he fields them.  Have him throw without a glove - put the tennis ball on the ground, have him pick it up and throw it.  As for batting, place the bat on the ground, have him pick it up and hit off a tee.  I remember helping out with a new kid in 7/8 yo league - figured out the kid was left handed but had been given a glove for his left hand.  Never did get him switched over fully.  Sort of like early writing instruction - be careful and do not assume the kid writes right handed.

Yea, I went out at bought him a right handed throw toddler glove when he was about 1, before he even threw a ball. I assumed he was going to be a righty and it was just a spur of the moment, put a smile on your face because you got your boy his first glove moment. He would put the ball in the glove on his left hand and throw it. Took about 10 minutes for me to realize I needed to put the glove in the closet and watch what he did when given the option. He threw about 60/40 in favor of LHP until about 2 1/2, and after that he always wanted to throw lefty and shoot his little tykes basketball lefty. We almost always throw without a glove, unless he picks one up on his own and wants to wear it with his Goldschmidt jersey. I have yet to see him step to the right side of the plate on his own. The only instruction/help I give is the occasional "no this hand on top" and "stand here" and of course the very first time where you show them what a swing is.

Originally Posted by lionbaseball:
Originally Posted by RGDeuce:

       
Originally Posted by 2020dad:
Why do I suspect a hoax here?  If so, kudos that was funny.  If this is legit...  I am not sure what to say.

Why would you suspect this is a hoax? Just looking for some advice/help. Or maybe I'm just overthinking the entire thing, in which case, I can take that feedback as well.


       

At 3 just make sure he is having fun because at some point baseball will become work. 
Just the other day my 16 y.o. told me he wants to start batting left handed. Lol

My kid used to practice hitting right and left with the hit-a-way.  At 15-16 started to switch hit.  Successfully.

 Gross motor skills are used for hitting, throwing, and kicking. And they often develop early in boys. Fine motor skills sometimes come later writing, coloring, cutting with scissors. If he likes hitting from both sides of the dish I would let him do it. If one side becomes more dominant than the other, a little boy will probably want to abandon the weaker (less fun) side.    Its all about fun at this age. When he gets older at 5 or 6 we can fly him in a switch hitting Coach!

Add Reply

Post
.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×