Skip to main content

our JV team is very young. we have 4 frsh who have never played, and a kid from germany that has never played either. 2 1/2 weeks isnt much time to catch them up to the intricacies of baseball. one of our new frsh was excited about the idea of going to first on a third strike. he just didnt know that it had to be on a third strike. so on the first, yes first, strike, the catcher drops it, he takes off to first. the catcher overthrows first and the runner that was on second (me) was going to third anyway on a steal and goes home on the overthrow. after discussion, the umps send the batter back and resume with the count. the run i score stands. many parents and coaches of the other team were absolutely irrate that the run counted. was this the right call? im sure its better than their suggestion that we are cheating and to throw us out.
The butt... it talks...
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Someone more knowledgeable about it than me can respond, but I'd say that's right. If the catcher was dumb enough to throw the ball around needlessly, then it should be treated the same as if he'd made a bad throw back to the pitcher and it went into centerfield. If the runner can advance, even if the catcher didn't throw it at all, then the runner gets what he gets. The batter has to go back and get a legit at-bat however.

Don't listen to the parents or coaches of the other team. I'd be very surprised if the coaches really think they were cheated. Instead of crying about it they should spend a little more time with their catchers.

Maybe your inexperienced batters know more about baseball than you think, that turned out to be an effective way to draw a throw and score a runSmile
Last edited by dad10

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×