Skip to main content

One of my New Year's Resolutions was to come up with some more topics for this forum. So here goes.

The strikeout. If a pitcher's best friend is the double play, where is the strikeout ranked? If the worst thing a batter can do is strikout with men on base what if he puts the ball in play and a double play is the result? Putting the ball in play against a team averaging several errors a game might be more intelligent than putting the ball in play in a force out situation with less than two outs.

Does this depend on the hitter, the situation, the pitcher or all the above?

TW344
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

TW334,
There could be three perspectives here: The pitchers, the hitters and the power hitters. When my son was pitching I always felt as if the strikeout was nothing more than a gift from the baseball Gods. When my son was hitting I always felt it was the baggage that comes with being a power hitter. I don’t think either the pitcher or the power hitter should allow the K to be a major factor in their approach. It is the timing of the K that makes it appear to be so huge. I agree with JBB in the goal of most hitters is to put the ball in play. A pitcher’s goal is to prevent him doing it with authority.
Fungo
Last edited by Fungo
Justbaseball:

I agree that a hitter never "wants to strikeout." Is there a situation, however, where you might want a hitter to bunt rather than simply try to "put the ball in play" [depending on the hitter, of course]?

I could see a situation where runners were on first and second with no outs or one out. To avoid the double play, why not bunt rather than take a chance on either hitting a ground ball or striking out.

There are probably more hitter/pitcher specific situations where bunting might be preferable to hitting.

Fungo: I am not sure I would make a distinction between the power hitter and the hitter. It seems to me that when both get two strikes, they need to change their mental approach. For the non-power hitter, his initial approach is to hit a pitch located in a zone he can safely hit the ball "where they ain't" to borrow a cliche. For a power hitter I would think the approach is to hit a pitch located in a zone where he can unload with a good chance of slugging a home run or extra base hit. But once they both have two strikes, to minimize the risk of a strikeout, they both need to make adjustments that would allow them to put any ball in the strike zone in play.

TRhit: I agree that pitchers with high K rates usually have high pitch counts,with all the implications that brings to their longevity, their innings per game and their complete game finishes. Sometimes the pticher that can induce the double play two or three times a game when the right situation exists [slow batter/runner] can help himslef out with all the above.

Thanks to everybody for responding.

TW344

Add Reply

Post
.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×