Runners on 1st and 2d. Grounder to SS, batter is thrown out and runners advance to 2d and 3d. Even though batter was called out, runner stayed on 1st and no one realizes he improperly stayed on the field so now bases are loaded but it should be runners on 2d and 3d base. Next batter gets up and is hit by a pitch. People now realize there was an extra runner on base. Of course, arguments ensue.
Umpires discuss with managers and decide that there was no harm done, hit batsman goes to first which should have been vacant and improper baserunner who was on 1st simply goes to the dugout.
Correct call? If not, what should the correct call be?
Original Post