UMW, formerly Mary Washington College, is still relatively small (about 4,000 undergrads I think). In my day it had only recently gone coed and was fairly open to anyone of the male persuasion, so sometimes we older folks don't realize how far it has come academically since those days.
The fact is, average SAT's of entering freshmen at UMW are third in VA, behind only UVA and W&M, ahead of Va. Tech and Madison. That fact catches a lot of people by surprise!
Baseball wise, they have one of the better playing facilities you'll see in DIII. They have a history of winning. A former teammate (just finished his freshman year) is there and enjoying it. Though I hate to tell you, he WAS recruited (around this time last year as I recall). He still had to survive fall tryouts and not everyone who tried out made it of course. So, just go in with your eyes wide open, take nothing for granted, and be ready to compete!
I will say they are not one of the schools you hear nightmares about (e.g., stories like recruiting 50 or more freshmen and then cutting a bunch of them in the fall, which does happen at some schools with regularity).